Yesterday on the podcast I shared about how “don’t be a stumbling block” is a toxic message to give to young girls about modesty.
It all stemmed from a discussion on Facebook where I was presenting a scenario where a 13-year-old girl was blamed for causing an adult man to lust in church.
You can see those posts here:
Post 1: Initial post on how thinking a 13-year-old is to blame for an adult man lusting is a red flag
Post 2: If you’re in a subculture where it’s assumed all men lust and that lusting after 13-year-olds is normal, that’s not a safe place.
Post 3: If you were ever given unwanted sexual attention at church as a teen, what were you wearing (to show it’s not about clothing)
The comments on Facebook were numerous (hundreds on each post) and all over the place. But some really stood out. And I thought today I’d just share a few that said something important.
First, when commenters started saying that 13-year-olds need to watch what they wear, commenters made some excellent points:
Thanks for providing more evidence that Sheila’s posts and work on this topic is necessary. The fact that so many women read a post about a grown man lusting after a 13 year old CHILD – and think the appropriate response to said post is to think teens and women need a modesty lecture is incredibly disconcerting. This is absolutely part of the problem.
Several comments showed concern for the CHILD, which is as it should be:
Girl come on. The correct response from a grown man to a girl who is deliberately trying to dress provocatively is, “Gosh that poor thing, it’s got to be so hard being a kid and feeling so much pressure to act sexy in our oversexualized society. I’ll be praying for her. Maybe my wife could invite her to the teen girls Bible study she runs. Lord, protect this sweet child from the evil in this world.”
Then, over the course of several threads and in several comments, I made these points, which I’d like to end on!
Of course we need to help girls see their worth. Of course. But the topic of this post is that a man is lusting after a child. The fact that we keep turning the conversation to “BUT THE CHILD….” is highly concerning. The main problem here is NOT THE CHILD, but the man. I think the fact that so many are focusing on the child shows that in our minds and our hearts we do not truly understand that men are to blame for lust, and that women and girls are not to blame for it. Until we understand that, we will continue to pass dangerous messages on to the next generation–messages that do harm their marriages. If you want to teach girls how to respect themselves, by all means do so. But please don’t do it in the context of a bigger conversation about men’s lust. That equates two subjects that should never, ever be equated.
You said that “Adults need to know it is never OKAY to lust after a child.” However, you said that in a thread where what you focused on most was fashion for children and girls. Can you see that, even if you give the caveat “adults should never lust after children,” if you make the focus of your discussion what is appropriate clothing and how girls keep wanting to show their butt cheeks, that you’re actually giving the opposite message? You’re saying adults shouldn’t lust and there’s no excuse, but then you’re going on and on with things that are excuses. You need to separate the two arguments. When we’re talking about adults lusting after children, that must be ALL we’re talking about. Modesty and dress should never, ever enter into the discussion. Have that discussion at another time, by all means. But when you conflate the two, then you’re giving the message, “Actually, sometimes it’s understandable that adults lust after children.”
It is very, very possible for men to control where their minds go. It truly is. Scientific studies have shown this; we also know that lust is cultural. We lust after what we’ve been taught to lust after. If you are in a subculture where it’s normal that men would lust after children, that isn’t safe. If you are in a subculture where, if a man lusts after a child, the first question is “but what was the child wearing”, then that is not a safe place for a child. Most men, when they realize someone is only 13, stop thinking of them in a sexual way. That should be the norm. This is what we should call men to, because this is what JESUS called men to.
Finally, this is how I ended a lot of the discussion (and you can tell I was getting testy):
And then maybe, just maybe, we need to change entirely how we talk about this.
You may also enjoy these posts on modesty and lust:
I really hope this can be our final word! But I’ll give you a chance now–anything else you want to add about modesty and lust? And how can we help the church stop talking about this in weird ways? Let’s talk in the comments!
Sheila Wray Gregoire
Founder of To Love, Honor and Vacuum
We're embarking on a new book project, and so we have a new survey! We hope you've all been...
I've been realizing lately I need to have compassion on younger me who was taught toxic stuff--and...
Is the next thing that's going to damage sex in evangelical circles the way that we're treating...
I remember a conversation with my husband around 1992 about how the church was totally on the...
Ever since The Great Sex Rescue published I've had parents ask me--how do we make sure our kids...
So if you've been loving what we've been sharing about The Great Sex Rescue--how do you make sure...
Healthy teenagers learn how to set boundaries. Well, healthy PEOPLE learn how to set boundaries!...
Is it bad to be your child's friend if you're also their parent? One of the pieces of advice we...