Some of the biggest heroes, to me, are the faithful men who stand beside their wives as they deal with the memories, trauma, and aftermath of sexual abuse–and help them heal.
And I want to talk about that today. This may be a bit of a different post because I’m typing it this morning, on a really busy day. Over the next few days I’m helping my daughter Rebecca move, and we have so much to do (and neither of us will be in the comments much!) But I have a ton running through my mind and I just want to get it out before I run.
Last week, when I got home from Ireland and Keith was jetlagged and sleeping and I couldn’t sleep, I binge watched the Netflix series The Keepers. It’s ostensibly about the unsolved murder of Sister Cathy Cesnik in Baltimore in 1969, but it’s really about why she was murdered, not who murdered her. She had discovered horrible abuse by priests and others going on at the girls’ high school where she taught, and she was about to reveal it.
I took three main things away from the show:
1. Older women are a force to be reckoned with.
I absolutely LOVED Gemma and Abbie (real-life women; the show’s a documentary). They’re in their 60s, they’re retired, and they decided that they didn’t want to die without knowing what happened to Sister Cathy. So they learned how to use Skype and the Freedom of Information Act and how to navigate government archives, and they compiled a better case file than any agency ever had. They’re so great. And when the media often portrays “women of a certain age” as being past their prime, this show demonstrated what an amazing force for good newly retired women can be. They were awesome!
2. The sins of an organization do not need to reflect on your faith or on God.
The Catholic church horribly violated Jean Wehner (the first of over three dozen abuse survivors to step forward) not because of the abuse (an evil man perpetrated that, and evil men are everywhere) but because of how the institution handled it and is still handling it. The bombshell in the last 15 minutes of the series of what the church knew and when it knew is quite astounding, and indicting. Even though the Archdiocese of Baltimore formally settled with victims and admitted their guilt in the early 2000s, it still has not told the whole story, to their everlasting shame.
(The Catholic church is the most visible organization to do this, but not the only one, as I’ll talk about later).
But the show does not say that everyone should throw away their faith or that God is dead. On the contrary. In the 1990s Jean starts having problems and has a feeling that there’s something really big in her past that she won’t let herself remember. She tries a bunch of stuff that doesn’t work, and then she just settles herself and tries praying. And that’s when the memories come. It is only when she’s quiet before God that he gently brings stuff back. She explains it in her words, and the documentary maker lets those words stand. And I liked that. Though she was hurt in a church setting, God was still there, just as God is here now. And the best people in the documentary are all people of faith whose church has betrayed them. But you get the sense that these lovely, everyday saints are the future of the church, and it will be okay.
3. A good man can be a amazingly healing.
That’s really my main point today.
Jean married her husband Mike soon after leaving high school, where she was raped repeatedly and often passed around by the priest to other men. The priest said horrific things to her about it all being her fault and part of her punishment for not getting better (she had originally gone to the priests for help with healing from her uncle’s sexual abuse).
She and Mike had the picture perfect family, until these memories started coming back. The couple approached the Archdiocese to report the priest, who was still working with children in another parish. They told them there was nothing they could do without corroborating evidence.
Jean comes from a family of 10 siblings. So the documentary shows pictures from the 1990s of all the siblings and their spouses and even their kids writing over 1,000 postcards to alumni from the school, asking them if they had any information on sexual abuse happening there.
About 50 women came forward with remarkably similar stories to Jean’s.
The church still did nothing (and neither did the police). So Jean and one of the other women sued. And here’s where stuff gets interesting with Mike.
Jean talks about how Mike had to sit behind her during a seven hour deposition, during which the church’s lawyers were picking her apart, and challenging everything. And she said, “He had to sit there when he wanted to jump across the table and strangle these people. And he had to swallow everything he was feeling, because if he said a thing he’d be kicked out of the room, and he knew that if he went, I’d follow.” So he swallowed it.
Later, in the court case, where she was being pulled apart on the witness stand, he had to do the same thing. “He had to sit there and swallow it while these people questioned everything.”
They didn’t win the court case (the statute of limitations had expired), and so they went on with their lives. But, said Jean, Mike had a plan of how he would murder Father Maskell. “The only reason he didn’t was that I begged him not to. If he did, the kids and I would be alone,” Jean explained. “And we’d really be the ones who would pay for it.”
The documentary shows touching home movies over the years of anniversary parties for Mike and Jean, and birthday parties. And then at the thirty-fifth anniversary they’re asked for advice, but Mike is sweet but rather quiet. And you start to wonder why Mike has never been interviewed for the documentary.
And then modern-day Jean explains, on camera, that Mike was so great to her, but that he always had to swallow down everything he wanted to say. He was never allowed to get angry.
And then these words appear on the screen:
“Mike Wehner passed away May 26, 2007, from esophageal cancer.”
All that swallowing down, Jean thinks, eventually killed him.
I saw those words on the screen on May 26, 2017. Exactly 10 years to the day of his death. And it hit me like a sucker punch.
That was a GOOD man. He was a faithful man, both to his wife and to God. He never let go of his faith, and he didn’t let Jean let go of it either. He was a great dad. And he stood beside his wife and protected her.
To have a man who would make plans to kill your abuser when nothing else works–I don’t know. I think that’s kind of cool. Obviously it’s wrong to murder and vengeance is God’s, but when you’ve been hurt, to have a guy desperately want to make it right for you? That’s an amazing thing (and kinda sexy, too).
That’s a healing thing.
I’m sure Mike and Jean’s marriage was really impacted from her abuse. I’m sure that things were never totally rosy, because she had so much to get over. But he stuck by her, and he never failed to fight for her and to separate what happened to her from who she was.
And I know today that there are so many Mikes out there.
There are men who weren’t abused themselves but who are survivors nonetheless as they walk through all of the garbage that their wives have to deal with. And these men are one of the biggest forces for healing that God uses, I believe. It must be hard to be patient, yet a good husband can be such a rock.
So today, to those men, I just wanted to say thank you. You make a real difference.
I was never a victim of abuse, but I was a victim of abandonment. And having a husband who can be righteously angry on my behalf is so cool. I’m always trying to forgive, and trying to move on, and trying to be healed (and I think I pretty much am), but when Keith gets mad–that’s great. I don’t let myself get mad really. I want Jesus to redeem that part of my life and have it not define me. But when Keith takes on that emotion that I don’t always let myself feel? So neat. So neat. So neat.
I don’t know how else to explain it, but those of you who have lived it, know.
Another word about church abuse:
I know there will be lots of pushback in the comments about The Keepers, and so I just want to say something else that I think is important.
I truly do not believe that this series was anti-Catholic–I think it was anti-Archdiocese of Baltimore (for good reason), but not anti-Catholic.
Here’s how I see the sex abuse scandal:
Being Catholic does not make anyone more likely to abuse.
But abuse flourishes wherever there’s a culture that allows it. When individuals (especially men) are given power over others; where there is a hyper-obedience to authority; where there is an ethos of protecting the community first and foremost; where there is an environment of secrecy–then there will be abuse.
I wrote a long article on this last year about what’s happening in conservative Christian circles that’s really important–let’s not make women powerless in the name of God.
It so happens that that culture flourished in the Catholic church in the 1900s. I do believe that it does not flourish today in the United States, which has largely cleaned up its act and really worked hard to protect kids. (I do, however, wish that the Vatican had not allowed Cardinal Law from Boston to retire there. I think that was a big mistake).
I also believe that the Catholic sex abuse scandal is not one of pedophilia but instead of homosexuality. The vast, vast majority of victims were pubescent boys, not young children. And the vast majority were boys.
Certain areas had more abuse because the seminaries were homosexual enclaves. Boston had about 6% of their priests abuse; Australia had 7%. In Ireland, the percentage was likely higher. But in some jurisdictions it was much lower because the culture in the seminaries producing the priests was different.
Again, it is about culture.
And the Protestant church is not immune to this. I have never talked about the Catholic sex abuse scandal on this blog until this week, but I have been quite vocal on social media and here about what I believe should be the shame of The Gospel Coalition. C.J. Mahaney, who used to run Sovereign Grace Ministries, knew that there was sexual abuse of minors going on in his churches. But instead of encouraging parents to go to police, he tried to hush it up. And then an abuser went to another church.
He had to resign from Sovereign Grace, but he has a new church. And last year The Gospel Coalition, with big names like John Piper, still had him keynote at their conference.
Look, abuse will always happen. We can’t eradicate it. But what we can do is treat it seriously when it comes to light.
That was the real scandal of the Catholic church–that it knew and did nothing.
And that is the scandal today of The Gospel Coalition. That it is still promoting a man and laughing about his legal troubles and his “persecution”. (Note: If people are mad at you because you did something horrendous, that does not count as “persecution”).
The other scandal is that too many conservative denominations have those same cultural markers–hyper obedience to males; an ethos of secrecy; little power for women. They are breeding grounds for abuse (as I will talk about tomorrow). And until we get real about this culture, the sexual abuse of children will keep happening.
I’ve been talking a lot about abuse this week–and tomorrow I want to turn to something closer to home: homeschoolers.
But for today, let’s talk in the comments: How can a husband be healing in your marriage? Let’s celebrate great men like Mike Wehner!
[adrotate group=”31″]
I completely agree with you that today in our ultra Christian conservative atmosphere, sex abuse thrives.
It’s sickening and the churches covet secrecy and blaming
Those who “point fingers” more than wanting to know the truth and let the whole congregation know what’s really going on.
It’s not just “ultra Christian conservative” environments. The institution which has the most sex abuse — both in raw numbers and percentages — is the public school system. Like religious communities, the teacher’s unions promote their own institutions and interests over those of children (and parents), will move teachers rather than fire them, will not report known abuse, and will attack victims when they come forward.
Any institution can be (and probably is) corrupt because humans. It’s why we need to be so vigilant in our own lives.
Totally agree. Although I have no personal experience, I have seen some documentaries about the foster system here in Australia that shows a lot of similar abuse.
I think that mistake the Catholic Church made (in its thinking) was that by hushing up the abuse, it was protecting God and the catholic faith, when in actual fact it was doing the opposite. I make the same mistake (on a smaller scale) when I sometimes don’t mention something difficult in my Christian faith to my husband (who isn’t a believer) because I feel that it might turn him further from the Lord. It took a lot of prayer for me to realise that God doesn’t need my protection.
God doesn’t need my protection. And with that knowledge, I can discuss any faith issues that I have with my husband, I don’t need to hide the ‘unappealing’ parts of Christianity from unbelievers, I don’t need to hide a Christ followers sins, because God is bigger than all that.
I think Christians (especially evangelical Christians) sometimes forget this. We get so carried away with doing ‘our job’ of bringing people into the faith, that we actually hinderJesus from doing His job (helping all the broken people).
I love the way your family speaks out about the hard and horrible things not just in this world, but specifically in the church, Sheila, I love your blog, and your heart for reaching out to the broken! Thank you for your ministry.
“God doesn’t need protection.” Exactly!
I believe sexual abuse of children is an evil act that will be indeed avenged by God. This act always breaks my heart and makes me want to hurt someone at the same time. It’s truly horrible that anyone would violate a helpless child in this most vulnerable way — but then to use the church as a tool to reach those victims?! That’s genuinely appalling.
The Bible is quite clear that such evildoers should not remain in our midst and certainly not be protected by our communities. Rather, Christians are called to “Defend the weak and the fatherless; uphold the cause of the poor and the oppressed” (Psalm 82:3). Thank you for speaking out.
Amen, J!
Could you explain how God will avenge the sexual abuse of children — or any sin for that matter (including yours)?
I’m so disappointed to read that open letter about the Gospel Coalition you linked to! I’ve personally found great benefit from articles on Desiring God, and now I’m having a hard time reconciling that John Piper with the one shown in the letter.
Is it possible for someone to have solid Biblical understanding in one area but to fail in another?
I think it is possible. I was totally rejecting the teachings of my upbringing because the teachers turned out to be horrible and hurt me very much. But I am finding I was throwing out the baby with the bathwater. Most of what they taught was correct. They just didn’t live what they preached. Their theology was straight they just didn’t practice it. That’s why God gave me my own brain. So I can search out if what I’m learning is actual truth and what is fallacy instead of totally depending on flawed people. I’m not great at it yet…
Yes, I think it’s very sad when people reject teaching because the teachers were bad. It just confounds the tragedy.
I don’t know, Kacey. I truly don’t know. It’s something I’ve been really wrestling with for quite a while now. I am so, so disappointed in the way that The Gospel Coalition continuously ignores huge issues of abuse in their midst. I don’t get it. I really don’t.
My wife underwent sexual abuse. We’ll be married seven years this July. Sometimes sex has been hard for her. She also struggles with being overweight and that causes her to experience shame in front of me, but as many know, including J from Hot, Holy, and Humorous who has already posted here, I am constantly showing her love and affection. I don’t post on Facebook on Sundays, but the other six days, I share something about marriage and a message about how much I love my wife. She is getting better in this area and being able to enjoy things. (By the way, to be clear, her family was in no way involved with the abuse.)
I do want to give one caveat about sexual abuse in the Catholic Church, and I say this as a Protestant. Obviously, one case of sexual abuse is too much, but we want to make sure we report the stories accurately as well. There’s a great book that has a chapter on this called “The New Anti-Catholicism.” It’s by Phillip Jenkins. The media often likes to go after anything Catholic when in reality, it looks like children are far more likely to suffer some abuse of some kind in the public school system.
The one “benefit” of a sex scandal in the Catholic church is that it is probably one of the few that can be assessed clearly. Some communities are so small (Amish, Mormon, Scientologist) and interlocked that outsiders really never get a view in; others are considered protected or favored classes (teachers here, Muslims in Rotherham, England) so their abuses are largely ignored or even actively covered up. Some, like in the Protestant church, are simply too loosely organized to ever have a wide-spread scandal. The Catholic church abuses allow us to do a fairly clear-eyed assessment of what went wrong and how it went so wrong for so long and the environment that supported it.
That’s very, very true!
I would add, not just Sexual Abuse (which is most pernicious), but any abuse requires a patient spouse. Sever emotional abuse provides similar challenges without the visible justification for when latent emotional problems become visible. As the husband of a wife who was emotionally abused in early childhood, sometimes I wish I could point to some specific act that created the conflict and difficulty. A childhood full of very poor parenting is more invisible a cause , but still results in visible problems. Abuse of children, in all it’s forms, has very long memory . . . measured not in years, but in generations.
So true, Jon! And a spouse can do wonders for bringing healing and breaking that cycle.
I was emotionally abused as a kid, and my husband was literally a godsend. I met him when i was 16. He’s one of the people who have kept me sane and helped me deal with the gas lighting from my family. It’s been a blessing to have someone who remembers the end of my childhood and can tell me I’m not the crazy one.
I’ve been slowly going through layers and layers of abuse and I’m sure it can be exasperating. But my husband had never judged me and has always accepted me.
That’s wonderful, Molly!
I tried to comment earlier but after I hit “submit comment” my comment never showed up. So I’m going to try this again and if I end up with duplicate comments, that’s why. 🙂
I also watched “The Keepers” and was both fascinated and horrified. But like you I also found moments of inspiration and encouragement. I loved how the husband of the other woman involved in the lawsuit supported her when she decided she wanted to go back to school to become a lawyer after their case was thrown out by the court. He turned a room in their basement into a study for her so she had a place to go that was quiet where she could focus. That reminded me of my own husband. I’ve been told I can’t do a lot of things for various reasons, but he has never told me that. If I tell him I’m thinking about doing something, he will do whatever he can to help me make it happen. I think he believes I could lasso the moon if I wanted to!
One of my favorite movies is “Spotlight”, which as you may already know is about the journalism team that blew open the Catholic abuse scandal in Boston. There’s a scene where one of the journalists is talking over the phone with a psychologist who used to be a priest but became a counselor and a psychologist and devoted his life to studying abusive priests (a real person). The journalist asks if he still goes to church, and the psychologist replies not any more, but he still considers himself a Catholic. The journalist asks “How does that work?” The psychologist explains that the church is an earthly institution, it will pass away. But faith is in something eternal. I was really surprised to hear a line like that in a movie. But it’s that concept that has been so healing for a lot of people who have been abused by authority figures in religious institutions, including myself. My faith isn’t in a church. My faith is in God, and Jesus went to the cross to give me direct access to God.
Also, have you read the book “The Witness Wore Red”? It’s one of my favorites.
Thanks so much for addressing this issue. I’d also like to add a shout-out to the wives whose husbands were sexual abuse survivors. My husband was abused by family members and it is difficult to go through the healing process when we live in a small community where the family wants to keep it all covered up. They have turned people against us in the Christian community. We used to attend the same church, but we have found a new church home. It’s very hard to work on processing, healing, forgiving, etc. when the abusive family insists forgiving means covering it up and not taking the time to deal with it. As if that is the Christian thing to do. So it was very refreshing to read your take on Mike’s righteous anger. I’ve felt a lot of that righteous anger myself! Thanks Sheila!
Sheila, i have always enjoyed the blog. But as you said the number of abusive priests was 6 to 7%. That is without a doubt 6 to 7% too high. And there was failure in church leadership. John Paul II said that if the church was to be saved, it would be by the laity. Now i am going to issue you a challenge: go talk to a catholic priest. Ask him if you can follow him around for a day. See what he does. Try to keep your sanity after your fourth trip to the hospital in a day to give the last rites to a toddler. Or maybe he is picking up a 95 yearold woman from the confessional floor in a weeping mess who just told someone that 80 years earlier she had an illegal abortion. And then when he hits starbucks to get some caffeine to make it through another night after he says a vigil mass, a woman with small children sees his collar and rushes her children away from him and scowls at him. The biggest victims of the catholic church abuse was of course the victims. Second biggest victim was the rest of the faithful. And i include in that the 93 to 94 % of priests who did nothing wrong and who continue to live out their vocation.
I have always been thankful for a godly husband who has never once made me feel that I was to blame, who has hurt with and for me, who has not allowed hate to fill his soul, and who has shown understand when something brought back memories even if it meant sacrificing his own desires/pleasure.
What a great man! What a blessing God gave you. That’s wonderful, and that makes me happy.
I was a victim of molestation by family members. This led to a very rock start to my teenage years where I was promiscuous in hopes of feeling loved. I grew up in a household that valued purity. I often told myself sex was bad or dirty etc. So I had a lot of shame from those years.
My husband not only has to deal with the original trauma but also the consequences of my teenage self. There have been many nights where his love and support feels so overwhelming I just sit there and cry in his arms.
He tries his best to understand what I have gone through but sometimes it still doesn’t make sense why I will push him away or get super upset when he is just trying to be intimate. This definitely makes him feel rejected.
We are working on communicating during the hard times and celebrating the good times. To be honest celebrating the good times is often harder for me. It is very foreign. Sometimes I still have to remind myself that I was intended to give myself to my husband and that is holy to have sex with him.
That must be so tough, Julianne! Healing is just so multi-faceted. I’m glad you have a good man to help you through.
Sheila – Just read your email in your weekly roundup and realized I had missed reading this article (read the others this week, though). As a lifelong practicing Catholic I think you have covered this subject fairly and am glad you made it part of your series this week. As someone commented earlier – God doesn’t need our protection. I will add: victims and vulnerable people do. Thank you for speaking for the voiceless.
Thank you, Erin! I appreciate it, and I love the way you put it.
As someone who has undergone abuse — THANK YOU to the husbands (and wives) who are there for their spouse. My husband has spent countless hours just sitting with me, holding me, going to counseling sessions (which he hates, but he goes anyway to support me), and even avoiding dramatic movies because they trigger unpleasant memories. Knowing that I’ve brought him into this is difficult, but I can never be thankful enough. We notice what you do; sometimes it’s hard to show thankfulness, but we are grateful.
Hello, I don’t know if you still read and reply to comments from older blog posts, but if you do, I’d appreciate hearing further comments on one aspect of this post.
I actually just started watching The Keepers based on this post. I really love your take on what is truly a disturbing story.
The only question I had was why you believe that homosexuality was such big cause of the abuse? Clearly in The Keepers the priests were acting out of a desire for power and control. The main abuser recreated scenes of the girls’ earlier abuses. How does that have anything to do with homosexuality? It’s all about power which is what rape primarily is.
You mentioned that many of the abuse victims in the whole church abuse scandal were boys, but again, wasn’t that about the types of people they had access to abuse (altar boys and the like) and again about power And not gender?
Do you think that the priests abused people because they were so tortured by suppression of their own desires that it came out in terrible ways?
I just can’t believe, and i would hope you don’t either, that homosexual people have a propensity towards child abuse more than anyone else. I know homosexual people. I care about them. They are no different than anyone else. I may not agree as a Christian with their sexual choices, but I also don’t agree with the view of sexuality that my friends who have sex with people they’re not married too, but I would never conflate that with child abuse.
Maybe you can clarify your comments on homosexuality and how it’s related to abuse of children by priests.
I was never sexually abused at least to the point of touching. There were other inappropriate things that went on though. And I felt my dad’s love was conditional on my behaving just right. Then I married a man who abused the 3 sons we had together. And his father abused one of my kids too.
Enter my current husband. He’s the one person in my life who I feel loves me utterly unconditionally. And he loves all the kids. Loves us all through all this brokenness. We’ve been married 8 years now and not once has he yelled at me. Not one time. He’s patient, gentle, loving and has soooooo much integrity. I feel like I can just BE. And honestly his love for me has helped me believe in a God who loves me unconditionally too. He is such a gift from Heaven. Truly.
Oh, Erin, that’s beautiful! Thank you for sharing.