Wifey Wednesday: Getting Over Your Husband’s Sexual Past

It’s Wednesday, the day when we talk marriage! I introduce a topic, and then you can all comment on it, or link up a post of your own that talks about marriage to encourage the rest of us!

Today I want to talk about something I get asked quite a bit: how do you stop doubting yourself because of your husband’s sexual past? How  do you stop feeling jealous of your husband’s former lovers, or stop worrying that he enjoyed sex with ex-girlfriends more than with you, his wife?

Getting Over Your Husband's Sexual Past

Now, it used to be that this wasn’t the topic for polite conversation in Christian circles, but I think that’s changed. When I was researching my new book, The Good Girl’s Guide to Great Sex, I surveyed 2000 women and about 400 men. And what I found was that of Christians, only 40% reported being virgins on their wedding night. So that’s a lot of people, even in the church, who are dealing with sexual baggage. And some sexual baggage is really hard to dump–especially when it’s part of your husband’s sexual past, and not just your own.

So I want to talk about this, even if it makes some uncomfortable, because I know many women are really struggling with this and want a safe place to talk about it and to go for answers.

Let’s look at a very common scenario: a guy has several sexual partners before he’s married. Maybe he even lived with someone before. He hasn’t talked about it much, but you know that he was quite adventurous in bed, or that he likely he tried a whole lot of stuff. Then you got married. And you? You were a virgin when you were married, or perhaps you had sex a few times but it was awkward and certainly not something to remember fondly.

And now when you’re making love, you feel like you have to live up to this image that YOU’VE created in your mind about what your husband experienced with other women. If he ever asks to try something new, you always wonder, “did SHE do this with him?” If you have a hard time achieving orgasm, you wonder, “am I a disappointment to him because he could satisfy another woman more? Am I frigid? Does he wish he was back with her?”

This can be even more difficult for women who marry a divorced man, or even a widower. “Does he miss her?”

A lot of women are plagued by questions like this–even women who are married to guys who swear up and down that they don’t want these other women and that they wish they hadn’t even had those relationships. This is one of the reasons, incidentally, that it’s so important to wait for marriage. These comparisons are very deadly.

But we still need to move on, so here are some thoughts:

1. You are Both New Creations

The most important thing you both need to do is to commit to living and believing 2 Corinthians 5:17: if anyone is in Christ he is a new creation. And not just that, but at your wedding “the two became one” in every sense of the word. You have something with your husband that is truly new.

In fact, I’d even have a ceremony–maybe a special dinner, or think up something symbolic you can do, like buying a butterfly necklace or something–where you agree that you are both new creations, and what you have is new and beautiful, and the old doesn’t matter anymore. And then you need to ask forgiveness from him for doubting him because of his past, and you need to commit to loving him here and now and not second guessing him. You need to promise that you will only see him through the prism of your own marriage, and not everything that you’re afraid went on before.

And then ask him to do the same thing. Ask him to think only of you, and not to worry or obsess over anything that happened in the past. You’re new! And make a commitment that from now on you both want to jump in and learn how both of you work together.

2. Take Every Thought Captive

We don’t have to entertain every thought that comes into our heads. 2 Corinthians 10:5 says, “and we take captive every thought to make it obedient to Christ.” In other words, when you have a thought, take it out, examine it, and then dismiss it if it doesn’t line up with what God says. And God says you are new creations!

So you need to stop entertaining those thoughts. One way to do this is to truly understand the difference between sex within God’s plan and outside of God’s plan. So when those thoughts hit you, say this to yourself:

I am going to stop assuming that he knows more about sex than I do because he had more sex than I did. Having sex is not the same as making love, and we are making love with each other. And to have a great sex life, we don’t need to understand “how to have sex”; we need to commit to learning how each of us individually works and what each of us individually needs. We’re both learning, because we both became truly and wonderfully sexual on the same date: your wedding night. Nothing else matters.

Did your husband sin? Yes. But don’t allow that sin to wreck your sex life now. Jesus paid the price; don’t keep punishing each other for it.

If it’s not a question of sin, though–if, for instance, you married a divorced man or a widower, you may have to tell yourself something slightly different, like this:

Making love is not a matter of understanding everything about sex; it’s understanding everything about each other. And it’s about how two people work together. We will make love differently than he did with his first wife, because we are different together than they were. And different is not worse! It’s us together that is beautiful, and we’re going to find our own equilibrium. If I keep worrying about his previous wife, then I’m robbing myself and my husband of being able to enjoy making love now.

3. Don’t Grill Him

If you’re already worried that he enjoyed sex more with someone else, grilling him on what he did with a past girlfriend/wife, or what he enjoyed most, or how she responded, is not going to help. It’s only going to give you images to fuel your anxiety.

Instead, be honest of your need for affirmation that you’re doing okay in the bedroom, but also, and perhaps this is the most important one:

4. Commit Yourself to Making Sex Great!

Then make it into a fun research project you do together. Tell him: I want to get to know all about you, and how you work, and what you like. And I want you to get to know me, too. I want you to figure out how to make me explode, because I’m not even sure I know. So let’s figure it all out together! If you do that, and move forward, then it’s unlikely either of you will be stuck in the past.

And try to have a new start. If you haven’t worked through the 31 Days to Great Sex, that’s a good place to start.

Finally, just make it a habit to show him what you like, and to give him lots of great feedback when it feels good! Guys like knowing that they can make their wives feel great.

It’s natural to wonder if you live up to your husband’s sexual past, but chances are your worrying is making it into a bigger problem than it needs to be. Your husband chose you. He wants to enjoy making love to you. Don’t let your insecurities rob you both of the intimacy God wants for you. God wants you to feel amazing, and to feel close, and to love each other. If you nurse jealousies, then you’re stopping something that God wants in your life. Who wants to do that?

Christian Marriage Advice

Now, what advice do you have for us today? Have you ever needed to get over a jealousy? Or do you have other thoughts to share? Leave a comment, or link up your own marriage post in the linky! Just leave the URL of your individual post below, and then remember to link back here so other people can read this great marriage encouragement!

31 Days to Great Sex
31 Days to Great Sex is here (only $4.99!) It's the best $5 you'll ever spend on your marriage!

Learn to talk more, flirt more, and even explore more! You'll work on how to connect emotionally, spiritually, AND physically.

Find out more here.



Comments

  1. Anonymous please says:

    Great post, but my personal scenario wasn’t there, and I could use your advice. My husband and I have been married over 25 years. We had sex with each other twice between getting engaged and our wedding (both Christians). We both asked each other’s forgiveness and God’s forgiveness before we got married. For the first couple of years, I had problems having sex with my husband because I felt so guilty about the premarital sex. I still occasionally feel guilty. I definitely still feel angry (and sad) that he didn’t respect me enough to wait for sex until we were married. (I realize I could have said no.) We’ve talked about it a couple of times over the years, and he has apologized again, but I still have those feelings sometimes. Your thoughts? Thanks!

    • I know that’s really a tough one, too. I have written about it before, and you can find that article here. I’d also encourage you to read this article about hitting the reset button on your sex life and starting over. Finally, just remember that while you may have done something wrong, Jesus already took the punishment for it. If you continue to punish yourself, and your husband, and deny both of you a great sex life, then it’s like saying Jesus’ death wasn’t enough. I know you don’t want to do that! So just meditate on how God really does want a new start for you, and doesn’t want you to bear this guilt today. I hope that helps!

    • I really don’t see that it should be an issue in your marriage NOW. You’re married. You’re united as one. To move forward and build a great marriage and a great sex life, you have to let go of the past. There are things that have transpired between me and my husband that we could hold on to – most of our relationship has been struggles. Harsh words, raised voices, accusations, abusive behavior, mental illness, even adultery – and yet we are so incredibly, amazingly happy now. Why? Because we both let go of the past. We both had a lot that we could have held on to, but we let it go because the past is the past, and we are both new creations. We are redeemed from our past sins and failures by the grace and strength of God. The things that happened may have been horrible, and they might have hurt, and honestly they could have destroyed us – but we worked through it, and because of those things we are stronger, we are closer, we are better as individuals and as a couple, and we really believe we’re happier because we have learned the meaning and strength of unconditional love, patience, forgiveness, and faith. Don’t let Satan put a wedge between you and your husband. The past is the past. Let it go.

  2. This was my scenario when my husband and I got married and I 100% agree with everything you wrote. He slept around quite a bit during high school and college and I was a virgin; we hadn’t had sex with each other before marriage, which was difficult for him not having had to wait for sex for anyone.

    I think it helped me too that on our honeymoon he told me that if he had known the freedom that came with married sex, he would never have had sex before marriage. Then, I knew that I was “the best” and I could always go back to that when I struggled with comparing myself to other women.

    It absolutely is a discipline to train yourself to not allow yourself to think about the other women. And to not ask about them. It is really, really hard. Eventually though, you do stop thinking about it as you build your own history with your husband.
    Elizabeth@Warrior Wives recently posted…Uncomfortable WordsMy Profile

    • Thanks for that insight, Elizabeth! I’m glad that you and your hubby have gotten over it!

    • This is really good @Elizabeth. I feel like I always want to know stuff & I feel okay as I’m hearing it (so inquisitive), but then I’m filled with pain. But, my hubs had said over and over… that there’s so much freedom in our relationship that he’s never experienced & that he never knew… in many ways… not just in the bedroom, which is always amazing! I’ve prayed for years that I’d always have a desire for my husband – esp since many of my Christian friends said, ‘call me six months after you’ve been married… and tell me if you still like it…’ Appalled, I began praying for a great desire for whomever he would be & that my desire would always continue to increase. I don’t know why I desire to ‘know’ things, I think remembering that everything from both of our pasts no matter how big/small is gone. It is no longer a part of our identity, so it’s not worth even recalling it or asking them to recall it. God is so amazing!!!!

  3. Thank you Shelia for writing about this topic. Being a widow and having married a widower this has come up in our marriage and it is a tough thing to get past when you have TMI. I am finding, slowly but surely, that grace covers this as well and that when I do take every thought captive and rebuke it immediately and then pray for my husband in that moment, thank God for the great gift he has given me in him, that ick feeling seems to diminish very quickly. It’s not easy, but I am seeing that those thoughts are not nearly as crippling as they used to be. I also really like your idea of a ceremony, acknowledging that we are new creations with each other. We may have to do that one! thanks!!

    • If you do the ceremony, let me know how it turns out! :) And I’m glad that God brought you together with someone else after your loss. That really is a blessing, even if it comes with baggage, as I’m sure you well know!

  4. I hadn’t thought about insecurity of his past affecting our marriage so much, but it really does. I guess we don’t have to prove ourselves better, we just need to enjoy and delight in them as they are.
    Sis recently posted…How To Handle Strong MenMy Profile

  5. Anonymous Too says:

    Very excellent post, Sheila! Though my husband had no active sexual past as your scenarios, he did look at porn in high school long before I’d ever met him. I found myself wondering all these same things and worrying over comparing myself to those kinds of things for years. My husband’s candor in the bedroom with me (“you were amazing”), and your book really helped me get past that. I think we women often have trouble truly believing the good things our husbands say and not enjoying and living and developing what we have now. I know I do. I have to remind myself that the past is past and stop fretting. Thanks again for the reminder. :)

    • I had the same struggles getting past my husband’s prior porn use, but the way he treats me, the way he looks at me, and the way he loves me leaves absolutely no doubt in my mind that he adores my body, loves our intimate life, and never compares me to the women in the pictures and videos from so long ago. He so honestly believes that I’m the most beautiful woman in the world – actually, the first time he saw me, he told his friends that he was going to marry me because I was that beautiful to him – and he still believes that I look exactly the same as I did when we were 18. The changes in my body (cellulite, etc) don’t faze him at all – he actually thinks it’s cute, because I’m HIS WIFE and he loves me with every fiber of his being. I feel so safe with him. I always felt insecure, and struggled with the porn issue for a long time, but in the face of his love for me it eventually became so easy to let it go, and it seemed so silly to hang on to it. He puts protections in place to avoid anything that he “doesn’t need to see” (as he puts it), so it’s not a current issue either. I love that man. :)

  6. Thanks for this post. No one ever talks about this very openly – even amongst friends. This is an issue for us – but kind of in a reverse twist. We were in our late 30s when we married and my husband had been sexually active, but I had not been. I was at peace that God would honor our new start together in that area. But my husband is the one who has struggled with guilt, shame, and comparisons from his past which has made our sex life stressful and not very fun. I am waiting and praying for God to heal this area of our marriage. I appreciate this discussion and keep up the hope.

  7. Thanks for this posting! My husband was a very sexual being before becoming a Christian, meeting and marrying me. He told me so. We were active before we got married, but we did refrain for the week before we married because he called it off. Now that we have been married over 16 years, we need a refresher course, so to speak. When I get the chance, I am getting your book!

  8. CoffeCrazed says:

    “It’s natural to wonder if you live up to his past, but chances are your worrying is making it into a bigger problem than it needs to be.” Good word.

    One thing I’d like to say and have seen it a lot on posts at themarriagebed.com, is that it is not only non-virgins that can bring baggage. Virgins, and especially those who have been immersed in purity programs, can bring their own baggage as well. There is a very long forum thread there originally posted by a young woman who was struggling with how to “remain pure” while her future husband was going to want lots of sex. She felt she might have to give in, if he fell, but really, shouldn’t he exercise self-control???? Here he is, a previously sexually active man, now committed to his relationship (and God, as I recall) with this young woman and has NOT crossed any lines with her.

    Who has the baggage in this circumstance?

    “For the first couple of years, I had problems having sex with my husband because I felt so guilty about the premarital sex. I still occasionally feel guilty. I definitely still feel angry (and sad) that he didn’t respect me enough to wait for sex until we were married. (I realize I could have said no.)”

    I lived under this specter for 20+ years in my marriage. Numerous efforts at confession and forgiveness, counseling, conferences, retreats. Nothing seemed to break through and I was the one left holding the bag of blame, even though she initiated regularly. It cast a pall over our marriage, particularly in the last 10 years.

    Ultimately, we all need to be gracious with our spouses and not hold each other to greater standards than God does.

    • Anonymous please says:

      You said, “Ultimately, we all need to be gracious with our spouses and not hold each other to greater standards than God does.” I like that statement. Because I know that God has forgiven us and we have forgiven each other, I can choose to honor God and my husband by refusing to entertain those guilty/angry/sad/disgusted feelings when they come. I can extend grace and kindness to my husband (and to myself). Thanks for your words.

  9. Though maybe not the most politically correct or loving thing to say, one simple statement by my partner really helped me get over my hangups with comparing myself to his past…

    The most comforting my partner has ever said related to his (very) active past was that with every new sexual partner he forgot about the rest. Meaning that it happened with me, too :)

  10. I struggled with this through our first year of marriage and sometimes I still have to fight it now. My husband was with a girl (and engaged to her) for 5 years before he met me. It has been a huge challenge to deal with the fact that he was even with her, let alone that they had sex together. I completely agree with taking your thoughts captive. I would let my thoughts and imagination run away with me. I found emails between the two of them on his laptop (from when they were together) and I read ALL of them and it killed me. It just fueled the fire. I had a really hard time coming to terms with my husband’s past and forgiving him. It was difficult because my husband had already dealt with his past, he had already sought forgiveness from God, so he didn’t want/need to talk about it. I did, however. I needed time to mourn in a way what should have been mine alone, to deal with the hurt, and learn to forgive him. It took time. I eventually had to just decide to let it go. He didn’t marry her, he married me. He loves me. He made a covenant with me. I shouldn’t hold his past over him and let it ruin our marriage.

    So now anytime this girl of his past comes to mind I have to take my thoughts captive and remind myself that I have forgiven him, that he loves me, and that I love him too much to let the past get in our way. It’s just not worth it.

    • I am still struggling with the same thing. Its eating me.However much I try to let go, I just cant. My husband only have sex with me once a month, and he told me he had never had a low sex drive before. This fueled me that he’s not attracted to me probably. I asked him if he’s attracted to me, and says yes.

      • I would say that might just be the marriage part. Just being comfortable being married, and all the ups and downs that goes along with it. I would take him at his word though. I’ve had the same problem with my husband, but things ebb and flow, so don’t blame yourself! And relish that he is attracted to you!

  11. I LOVE how you reminded people that we are new creatures in Christ. I think we all need to be reminded of that wonderful truth over and over! Then we need to start living that way since we can do all things through Christ who strenghthens us.
    Lori recently posted…Men’s Wandering EyesMy Profile

  12. Sheila – Great (as always) thanks.

    I’ve done some study on the difference between casual sex and sex in a deeply commited long term relationship (in other words, marriage) and they are very different. Men act different, are far more selfish, don’t really care about her desires and needs. Women are far less likely to enjoy casual sex. What that means is his past sex is hollow compared to what he has with his wife.
    Paul H. Byerly recently posted…Control issuesMy Profile

  13. So been there but on the opposite end. I was like Rahab. However, my man was married before, yet he remained a virgin until they married. After she divorced him, when we were dating and engaged, we remained pure, but the comparisons of my past haunted me for a long time. I had to dwell on the Word of God to get over my issues.
    Jolene @ The Alabaster Jar recently posted…9 Things About My Sex Life that I’d Share with a Young WifeMy Profile

  14. My husband and I were both virgins when we got married– not because we had such moral fortitude. Frankly, it was because we were both very young and scared to death of what my parents would do! That said, I find myself at a loss when it comes to this subject because anything I say seems, well, silly. (I’ve been married for over two decades.) Thank you for your post and your insights. Very helpful. I know this is a very difficult subject and needs to be handled with sensitivity and wisdom.
    Christi Marcotte recently posted…What Do I Do With A Twitter Follower Like THAT?My Profile

  15. Thank you so much for this. I am in the aftermath of my husband’s confession that he was not the virgin I thought he was when we got married. He also had a 25-year history with porn that developed into more, and I was unaware of it all. I am so relieved to see practical Christian counsel that helps me address all my questions and feelings with truth. Thanks for writing on these topics!

  16. I appreciate this post. The situation I’m dealing with is really hard- abuse. My soon to be hubby actually performed some acts of sexual abuse (not sex, mind you) on a family member. I know that sounds terrifying, and trust me, I was terrified when I found out and almost broke off our engagement. But God has shown me time and time again that he is changing my guy, and that’s he’s not the boy who hurt that girl anymore. I know that it takes the power of God to confess something like this and actually seek out the help that he needs to face his past, and he’s doing that.
    But still, my trust in him is so far from where it was prior to the news. I’m starving for advice, some book or something. It’s such a hard thing to deal with, and I feel like I’m the only one who’s ever been through this and I have to figure out how to deal with it and it’s really hard.

    • Emily, that’s really, really a tough one. I would tread very, very carefully since you haven’t actually married him yet. That’s wonderful that he’s getting help, and that he’s repentant, but something like that is a really big deal, and you could be opening yourself up to a world of hurt if he doesn’t really change.

      Now, it could be that he has changed. But I would give it some serious time, and I would surround yourself with some very wise mentors who can guide you through this: people who know the background and can help talk to both of you. I just wouldn’t rush into anything.

      It is absolutely possible for someone to change; but sexual abuse also has its roots in so many deep seated problems that you are probably signing on for a lot of issues in your marriage, even if he doesn’t reoffend. And if he does, that’s a whole other story. So I would make absolutely sure that you can trust him again, and I would find some Christian mentors whose opinions you trust and value to help guide you through this!

      I’ve said a prayer for wisdom for you,
      Sheila.

  17. Would you say that in having sex before we marry we are sinning against our future spouse?
    My husband and I are stuck on this issue. I say that in having sex with various women before we met he gave away what was meant for me, that in a sense his body was mine even before we married. He says he sinned against God only and deprived me of nothing because his body became mine once we married.

    • Maria, I’d say technically you are correct: he didn’t give you what you deserved. HOWEVER, that’s really a bit of a moot point, because the truth is that he can’t change it now. All you can really do is move forward. I think if you keep arguing the point then you’re just going to drive a wedge between the two of you. It is too bad that he didn’t wait, but he can’t change that now. All you can do is to agree that you both want real intimacy now, and work at achieving that, rather than punishing him for what he did before. I hope that makes sense!

      • Thank you so much for the quick answer!
        I agree there is nothing that can be done now, and I’m not looking for that. I don’t even need him to apologize, but I do wish he could aknowledge that I did lose something real. In our ongoing discussion he’s been asking me to biblically prove my point. Any suggestions?
        We’ll be talking to a pastor soon, hopefully we can fine an agreement and move on.

        • I think what’s happening is that you’re going round and round on something which isn’t the main issue.

          Here’s what you need: You need him to acknowledge that you are hurt.

          Here’s what he needs: He needs to know that he is off of the hook with you, and that you can move forward and have an awesome, intimate life anyway.

          I think you’re arguing about a theological issue when the real issue is how you feel about it. Can you say something like that to him? Just tell him something like, “here’s what I think we both need. Do you think that’s true?” And then try to work towards acknowledging each others’ feelings and reassuring each other, without necessarily agreeing with each other. Do you know what I mean? He doesn’t need to agree with you biblically, but he does need to acknowledge that you’re hurt. Similarly, you don’t need to agree that he did nothing wrong to you, but you do need to reassure him that from here on out you can build intimacy and remain close.

          I think if you focus on the needs/feelings rather than the doctrinal argument you may get further ahead.

          I hope that helps!

          • Ok. But you see he does aknowledge that I’m hurt, only he says I have no reason to be hurting because I wasn’t wronged. So his aknowledging my pain doesn’t help very much because in essence (not in these terms of course!) he’s telling me to suck it up and this doesn’t help closeness at all. And I do want to know what the Bible has to say about this issue (if it does), for my own peace of mind not to win a debate. If what I am feeling has no biblical basis then I want to conform myself to what God’s word says i should be thinking and feeling, and feed my heart with Truth instead of lies.
            Sorry I’m insisting so much, but I don’t really have someone to turn to for sound advice and work this through in person, so thank you for your patience :)

          • I still think the process of trying to figure out whether you have a right to feel a certain way is very counterproductive and dangerous, and isn’t a helpful one to engage in in marriage. There are times when feelings are illegitimate; feeling wounded that your husband had sex before he was with you is not one of them.

            This may be a good issue to sit down and talk to a third party about. It is likely an issue you will keep having in your marriage–conflict about whether you have a right to feel a certain way. If you could talk through that issue and look at a more constructive way to deal with it I think that would be important–even more important that the original question of whether or not you were sinned against.

            And yes, you were. If sex is only in marriage, and he had sex outside of marriage, then he sinned against his wife, in the same way that the Prodigal Son tells the father “I have sinned against heaven and against you.” But that’s not the real issue; the bigger issue is how you resolve conflict and deal with your feelings, and I’d really recommend talking through THAT issue rather than the one about whether or not he sinned against you, if that makes sense.

  18. Before we married, my husband had several partners in the past and was sexually active with them, and I was virgin & having him only till our wedding night. We knew this from the pre-counseling marriage with our pastor, but did not get onto the details.
    Days before the wedding, I found lots of past love letters, dirty mails, kinky stuffs that related to their past activities and that hurted me so much (even some I still found after the wedding, but he allowed me to erase or throw away whatever I find). I was even thinking about cancelling the marriage, as I can’t beared this stuff. At that time my thought was: I have been waiting for so long for a man that deserved me, and I don’t give away my virginity randomly because my future husband should worth it.
    That evening we were crying together the whole night, he kneeled on and asking for my forgiveness.
    He swore that he never love them and they’re meaningless for him, regretting it as wishing us to meet much earlier, and telling me I’m the only one he ever love and the one he wants to stay with till the end of his life.
    After being hurt so bad, I’m not easily believe him but with his powerless condition, I decided to continue the marriage anyway. I cried out on our wedding day….

    After we married, I can see (even up to now) he is trying his best to cherish me and sacrify everything to make me happy.
    Even after I got pregnant, he really spoiled me and treated me like his queen. Many friends even envy me on how my husband treated me.
    With the sex life, sometimes I feel he’s not really interested in me anymore as he already waste his power and lust to those oldies women. He clarified that wasn’t true and telling me that he wanted to be gentle to me, dont want to use me as his sex-tools, and would welcoming me whenever I want to have something with him. And that he wanted to make things started up new again with us after my paradigma about him.

    Sometimes I still really seriously struggled with this issue (my husband knows it without I tell him). But I pray to Lord everyday that I can really trust & love him back, and love him truly, like Christ did to me and all of us the sinners.
    He might be the best husband I can ever imagined, that God has given to me. I just want to look on the future together with Christ as my main life objective above all, and him as the partner beside me.
    I believe He is near to us whom heart are broken, and in Him – we are the new creation.

  19. I am so heartbroken. I had a horrible 1st marriage, but stuck it out and prayed and prayed for strength to get through it. I finally realized through the help of my Pastor that my ex was not well, and no matter what I did, things would not get better. I went through the divorce, and unbelievably found a wonderful man. We have been married for about a year and a 1/2 now. About 3 months ago, I discovered something awful about him. For the two years before he met me, he engaged in Cyber Sex with a lot of women/young women. He also cruised nasty porno sites on the internet. I confronted him about it. He answered all my questions honestly, and burned the laptop he used for this. We have no computer in the house anymore, and I do feel better about it. However, I feel very confused and unable to open up to him sexually anymore. I don’t know what to do.

  20. anonmouse says:

    Oh, I struggle with this daily! I’m living with my fiance, to be married in a couple weeks. We’ve been sexually active. But I’ve asked too many questions got TMI and now im really freaking out. I’m not a virgin, but this will be my first marriage. He was married before, and during that marriage had multiple affairs which I have confirmation of. Then after his divorce he was even more sexually active and I’ve run into things like pictures of previous explicit rendezvous on his cell phone, sexting, and videos. I can’t get them out of my head! Yes they were before me, but I can’t shake the doubts and have trust issues. With the fact that he cheated on his first wife, and I’ve been cheated on in my past, how to I break this mindset. I can’t sleep at night I’m so full of worry. Please pray for me!

    • Sheila says:

      Oh, sweetie, I don’t know you, but your story raises major red flags for me. You’re living with a man who has already had multiple affairs on his previous wife. Unless there has been a major change in his life–a spiritual awakening, for instance–it is VERY unlikely that he is just going to become a totally different husband for you. Perhaps the reason you’re having trouble trusting is because God is trying to give you a nudge that he’s not trustworthy. Be very, very careful before marrying someone who has a history of cheating.

  21. Hi. My situation is kind of weird. My husband had a revenge affair on me which involved intercourse with another woman. Needless to say I am still devastated but what is bothering me more and more is this. When I cheated about a decade ago, the farthest I went was to be fondled inside (fingered). He says he went all the way with her because he didn’t believe I didn’t have sex with this guy (my husband and I were having sex with each other at the time). Long horrible story short, it is haunting me that he has had intercourse with one other woman besides me and shared the ultimate with her when he is the only one I have had intercourse with. I actually am trying to reconcile with him, but I can’t seem to get past this. What do I do?

  22. AngelBlue says:

    Dear Sheila,

    This post has really touched me. I am dealing with this and a little more. I am newly wed to a man I love very much. My husband has a child with his ex and is paying child support. She is a horrible person, and I am not being biased. I have been trying to look for the good in her, but she has made it very difficult. She has been very selfish and all she wants is child support. She even wants to deny him his rights as a father (she even almost got away not putting his name in the birth certificate), but still wants child support. Now, I knew about his past and he has asked me for forgiveness about this, admitted that it was a mistake and he stumbled, that I wasn’t in his life then. I thought I could handle it, but I just can’t shake it off.

    We see her on a regular basis and she always dresses like a “slut” (pardon my language), always flaunting her huge breasts and all. Her past is checkered with men (around 12 men before my husband, one of whom was his friend!), and I hate that it was my husband that got her pregnant. When I see or think about her, I get troubled by thoughts of how my husband had sex with her. To make matters worse, I find that whenever I see his son, it brings back horrible images of my husband and her having sex and how he made her pregnant! I don’t know what to do, because we have been having trouble conceiving, and I am just consumed by jealousy.

    I’ve openly discussed with him about how it hurts me to think of the way he made love to her and now he’s doing the same with me! It pains me to know but the truth is the truth I can’t change the past. Am I being stupid or selfish? I want nothing to do with her or keep thinking that my husband once slept with her, had sex with her, made a baby with her…nothing at all.

    I don’t know what to do… I fight with my husband about this a lot, and he has been trying to make it up to me. But how? I hope and pray that I take the advice in your article. God help me.

  23. What scares me is that my partner may have enjoyed sex more with someone from their past? That they got more pleasure than I could give them. That I would never make them feel as good sexually as that other person, and I am not sure I can live with that. I have to be the best and know that I am the best, but I feel that they would never truly be honest with me for fear that they would hurt me. That scares me as well, that I may never know. I just don’t know what to do about this, and I don’t see any way of solving this. How can I know that I am their best and not always wonder and worry about this, I cannot be second rate, I have to be their best? I sincerely hope you can help

    • Emily, I feel your pain… I am going through the same thing. I feel like I’m taking seconds of everything… I don’t think I can live with it either. :(

      • I just wish I knew it was better with me. My friends just think I’m crazy and that I place too much emphasis on it but they haven’t had to deal with this, they don’t understand how this can affect intimacy. They just keep telling me about they would rather have their husbands even if they weren’t “pure” (the word makes me cringe) because they love them and that should be enough. And they tell me about how I’m being selfish but they don’t get it, they don’t understand because they were both virgins when they got married, they just think its a non issue. I get that love makes the difference but it still hurts me. It’s not right that my partner’s past hurt me, and they got to enjoy sex with someone else. I feel like I’m the only one that lost here.

        My friends try to tell that even if they don’t enjoy it as much with me, they still choose to be with me because my spouse loves me. The problem is, I don’t think that’s enough. I have to be better. I have to be the best, I can’t live with my spouse enjoying sex more with someone else, with feeling inferior to another person in this regard.

        And I feel like God loves my friends more than me because He took care of them, made it where they would not have to deal with this. I just want to go, “why didn’t You take care of me like you did them?” I am so frustrated. And everyone just acts like its no big deal.

        I just want to know that it’s better with me, I at least feel like I can live with that. I understand that it’s not a number thing; it’s not about me not being his first. They didn’t give their ex anything they haven’t given me. Their ex doesn’t possess their virginity. Virginity is a state of the peron not an item that someone holds. Their ex does not possess anything that I don’t they’ve are not holding it over me. It’s just that what should have only been mine was given to someone else as well. It just makes me feel like I’m not as special to them as they are to me.

        How can I know my spouse enjoys it more with me than one of the exs? That its more passionate with me? What do I do?

        • I’ve been struggling with similar things myself (my wife had sex with a boyfriend in high school, in addition to fooling around with 2 other boyfriends). My biggest thing is wanting/obsessing with knowing everything that she shared with them. I know enough already to make constant comparisons – she’s said that she never thinks about them, but on occasion has said things to tell me that she finds it very easy to recall at least some details if she ever feels like it. She’s told me that she doesn’t want to talk about it in detail because she doesn’t want to think about it herself, now that she’s successfully repented of it and changed her life (which she certainly has – 5 years no dating/chastity before we got together – but we’re 17 years married now and I’m still struggling).

          I’m pretty sure that at least part of my wanting to know is to ‘make sure’ that she’s actually sorry for it all. Since our dating days she’s been cautious with me, physically and emotionally at least. I want to know that she’s not avoiding certain things with me (emotional sharing as well as sexually) simply out of wanting to avoid memories of those guys. I’ve got issues that I obsess over – she told me that maybe she should have married a non-virgin/I should have married a virgin – even before she told me that she regretted sleeping with him (it bugs me that she basically told me that she regretted getting married to me before she thought to say she regretted what she did back then). Once in the past year she asked me if I thought we should separate to help work things out (not intended as a divorce precursor) – then later told me that she regretted saying that to me.

          I obsess with how easily/quickly she shared her body with that boyfriend, while I can’t have a completely open conversation with her about those same experiences after 19 years together and 17 years of marriage – there’s still often tension and hurt when we talk about it. Then I feel guilty (probably justifiably) because I’m not loving like 1 Corinthians – but I don’t know how to change my emotions from what they are – I tried repressing them for many years – which made my issues come out other ways – it’s only from directly facing them that I feel like progress has been made. I want to know how she broke up with him – did she say something like, “you’ll always be my first”? Does she still somehow consider it ‘special’ what she shared with him? How did she talk about it with her friends at the time? How did she talk about it with him?

          I understand your issues, but I also understand that on some level we have to be able/willing to let go of those past relationships. One thing that drives me crazy is how she says that she’s over her past, and that I should be as well – it doesn’t acknowledge the pain she brought into ‘us’. Then I also think maybe I’m being oversensitive. I’ve long thought that maybe I should just go track him/them down and confront him/maybe fight him, and try to be done with it. I’ve basically been yearning to confront things directly these past years, and this would be in accord with that.

          Have you tried counselling Emily? I’ve tried low-level a bit (with our parish priests at a few different parishes over the years – but nothing that has resolved anything for me) – I may look for a good counsellor sometime – I just don’t like/see the point of talking to someone else when what I want to do is talk openly with my wife. I don’t want to resent being able to talk with someone else and not her.

          • Shane,
            Sounds to me like you’re obsessing over something that’s really out of your hands.
            You being a virgin @ marriage with her is good and should be encouraged.
            However, all this going over her past in your mind won’t help your marriage.

            She was chaste for 5 years after losing her Christian innocence. Doesn’t that tell you anything about how she regretted it?
            She’s a Christian AND a sinner, just like you are. Christians sin and make mistakes and regret those.

            You say:
            “….I’m pretty sure that at least part of my wanting to know is to ‘make sure’ that she’s actually sorry for it all. …. she told me that maybe she should have married a non-virgin/I should have married a virgin – even before she told me that she regretted sleeping with him (it bugs me that she basically told me that she regretted getting married to me before she thought to say she regretted what she did back then)….”

            Shane, are YOU the one to forgive? She told you she was sorry. Isn’t that good enough for you?
            Once in the past year she asked me if I thought we should separate to help work things out (not intended as a divorce precursor) – then later told me that she regretted saying that to me.

            “….I obsess with how easily/quickly she shared her body with that boyfriend, while I can’t have a completely open conversation with her about those same experiences after 19 years together and 17 years of marriage – there’s still often tension and hurt …I tried repressing them for many years – which made my issues come out other ways …. I want to know how she broke up with him – did she say something like, “you’ll always be my first”? Does she still somehow consider it ‘special’ what she shared with him? How did she talk about it with her friends at the time? How did she talk about it with him?…”

            Are you replaying movies in your head of what it was like for her when she surrendered her virginity to him?
            That will only torture you.

            You need to think of it from her perspective. Perhaps the guy pressured or sweet-talked her, or threatened to leave her if she didn’t give-in, which often happens.
            Love/ lust are hard things to avoid.
            Clearly, she realizes it was a mistake. She didn’t go out and sleep with every guy she dated in the 5 years after losing her innocence before meeting you. And she didn’t pressure you to make love with her either.

            I always advise couples to discuss their sexual pasts, but not early in the relationship. Wait until you’re emotionally close.
            The other does need to know what he/she’s “buying.” But such discussions should only be in generalities, not specifics, as such information could easily hurt the other who was hoping for something else.

            I wasn’t a virgin @ marriage in my 30s but that didn’t mean I had had a lot of sex. Far from it. Only 2X throughout all of my 20s outside of some highly regrettable sex in high school before I became of faith next year in college.

            Was stunned when a 30 y.o. virgin I dated from a church singles group I was involved in @26 nearly came to tears when I simply told her I wasn’t a virgin like her.
            Now, didn’t say how many/how often, but it really hurt to see her unforgiveness & judgement.
            If I was quick thinking, would’ve told her “Look, I really wish I was a virgin & had waited if I had known I would meet a nice girl like you. I really haven’t had a lot of sex and to be honest, am quite naive about it. I am a Christian and know what sin is. Please don’t be mad at me about it. I wasn’t having sex to deliberately hurt you….”

            As it turns out, my wife wasn’t a virgin either but like me, didn’t have a lot of experience, so it worked well for us.

            You really needed to go over some of this with her before you married.
            She chose you, Shane, not any of her other boyfriends.

  24. I’m am married to my husband for to years and the jealousy to his past is not releasing me. Before marrying to him i knew that he had other partners (almost all men do) but he didn’t offer to many details so i thought that is wasn’t something major. I felt in love with him so bad that i almost idealized him. I am a person of strong moral principles and i married virgin. After our marriage he started to open the topic about his past and sexual and slowly the details were coming up. They were terrifying me. Those details were coming in middle of conversations about his single or married friends and their sinful sexual life and he is talking in a way that makes you feel that he just knows all that himself in practice.He slept with many women and bitches i think as he traveled in many “exotic places” with striptease and private parties. Now he ensures me that he changed and he is a completely different person and he loves and wants me only. I cant forgive him. Anytime the topic comes about men who cheat and sleep with indecent women or men with hot sexual past, i get jealous on his past. Can’t help myself it’s torturing me. I want release the past and enjoy my happy present but i just cant forgive his sins as sometimes they make me feel disgusted by him and give me mixed feelings of love and hate.
    I am thinking to visit a psychologist to give me advises on how to deal with ghosts from the past.
    Can anyone please give me any advise or mental exercise or anything that can make me stop thinking on this over and over again

  25. Thank you, this really helped !

  26. Thank you so much for this article! I’m going to get married in a month and I really didn’t have any problems or thoughts, but recently doubts and fears started creeping in. I knew I needed relief and I didn’t want to pour salt in the wound of my amazing fiancée. This article helped me out a lot! Especially the part about the difference between having sex without the Lord’s sanctification and making love as husband and wife.

  27. Thanks for this post. I am working on a situation like this in my life now. The part I have trouble with is that people say their husband had several partners, well, mine had around 100, 50 of which he actually remembers a name. He is now a Christian and we have been married 2 years. I love him, but sometimes think I can’t keep going. The pressure of this is really affecting me. I thought I could live with it, but there are days I just want to quit trying. He never wants to talk about it. He says it is in the past and we should never let it hurt our relationship now. The past is the past…but I can’t get the images out of my mind…

    • Hi Sue,

      I know that’s really difficult, and yours is probably a situation that most of us would find overwhelming. But I’d just say one thing: you married him knowing this about him. Yes, what he did was horrible, but you still married him. And so now the ball’s in your court. He can’t change it; all you can do is to decide to move on. And if you don’t, in a way you’re being unfair. I know that’s really tough, but that’s just the way it is. He can’t make it up to you, and it’s really no wonder he doesn’t want to talk about it. But the time to decide that you can’t live with it was BEFORE you got married, not after. Now you’ve made that commitment, and so you have to do whatever you can to see him through the same eyes that God sees: totally redeemed and totally clean. That IS possible. I know it seems far-fetched, but God so wants to do that in your life. Will you let Him?

  28. I realize that this is an old post, but I just read it for the first time. I have a similar situation. My husband had sex with two of his girlfriends before we were married and he is the only person I have ever had sex with. I know he would undo it if he could, but my issue is just that the Bible says that even if a man joins his body with a prostitute, they become one flesh. This worries me because to me it sounds like he and I aren’t actually “one flesh” since he had sex with other people before me, and does that mean that I am sinning by being married to/having sex with some one who might be one flesh with another person? Or is the bond of marriage stronger than that?

  29. ChildofGod says:

    I’m in a relationship with a man who has had multiple sexual partners. I have never had sex before and plan to remain a virgin until our marriage.

    I have never met a man so in love with God. He inspires my walk with The Lord and pampers me with love and care. I feel so blessed that he is in my life. Before dating my boyfriend, I was positive that dating someone with a sexual past was plainly out of the question. The were “unlovable” and “unworthy” of my love.

    I was so wrong in thinking that way. I truly believe that God blessed me with my relationship because he changed my sinful view of what I thought love looked like. God has taught me that although someone may have sinned sexually, they are forgiven, made new in Christ, and are redeemed because of what Jesus completed on the cross.

    That being said, finding out about my boyfriends sexual history was not easy. I deal with insecurities and unpleasant thoughts regurlarly, which is something I am working through. I know God is mending my broken heart daily. Yes, I wish I was marrying a virgin. But without meeting my boyfriend, I would have continued thinking that people like him are impossible of loving.

    It’s difficult because in the Christian community, premarital sex is the unforgivable sin. Almost every sermon includes the “disastourous” outcome of premarital sex. This in itself makes the forgiving process difficult for not only myself, but also my boyfriend.

    I could continue writing forever, but the bottom line is that premarital sex is a problem that many young men are burdened with. That isn’t an excuse for their behavior, but it’s a reality in our culture. I’ve met a man who understand that he messed up, but I feel the spirit of The Lord growing in him. He is a gift. I’m just as guilty of thinking my boyfriend was unlovable for him actually having sexual relations.

    It’s a hard process, and I need all the prayer I can get. But I know God loves me, and is holding me. He protects his children, and I have to have confidence that his redemption will restore my relationship completely, making our marriage strong in all aspects.

    However, I do have one question, and it might have an easy answer- I just don’t know! in the bible it says that having sex with another person transforms 2 people into 1 flesh. Before marrying, I want to know what this means/how to understand. Anyone that knows please help!

    • I believe the two become one flesh under the covenant of marriage, and the sex seals the deal, but it obviously doesn’t keep the deal- the two people and God do. Though Paul talks about not hooking up with prostitutes, because it is a sin inside the body, the person is not bound to them. From someone who is the female version of your boyfriend, first I would say, it isn’t anything that anyone wishes to do before marriage. We all start out wanting to only have it with that one person forever. Once you engage in the sin it isn’t fun because of the guilt, but strangely the sin is easier to do, even though it is a let down because of all the negative things attached to premarital sin. Remember you are the blessed one! When you experience it it will only be with joy- not with all the terrible insecurities, etc. He is too, but because he met you and is waiting for you. Don’t think that if you do get married he would ever think of anyone else. You will be his all in all under God. Trust me it’s not what he thinks about- it’s you!

  30. 40% were virgins when they got married? You must have had an very limited pool of people from which you sampled; like maybe people who got married at age 18 and lived with their very strict parents up until the wedding day No doubt there are some people who wait for that wedding day . . . yet reality is reality, and most don’t. This is especially true when those who might have only had sex with their now spouse, but didn’t wait for the wedding to happen first. The stats are very real, at high school graduation, less than 50% are still virgins. And by the end of the first year of college (or the working world equivalent), only 20% are (a year away from the direct supervision of mom and dad tends to be very risky scenario for one’s virginity. And certainly, by the time four years of college has past, well, we are below 10%. Now don’t get me wrong, I’m not suggesting that everyone is just sleeping around all the time; all I’m saying is that over 90% have at least done it one time. I hung around the Christian crowd in college; they were great people, and most had the best of intentions; but most of them “fell” somewhere along the way.

  31. Thank you for such a good article on this topic from a Christian standpoint. While it covers some important information I didn’t see anything that handles my situation and I could really use some advice from a Believer. My husband told me before we got married that he was not a virgin. We met with a premarital counselor and I worked through a lot of the hurt/fear I had from his past because I knew that he had repented and changed. Our first few years of marriage he was always really good at making me feel secure and telling me he doesn’t compare me to the past but lately it has been obvious that he is not completely happy with things. He finally admitted that he does compare our relationship to past ones and that ours is not as satisfying but that he is choosing our relationship over that satisfaction. I feel like my worst fears have come true. How do we move forward from an acknowledgement like that? I don’t want our marriage to fall apart but I don’t know how to handle or heal from what he said.

  32. I have been married to my husband for almost 13 years now. He was sexually active before me with a few girls. Each one he was in a relationship with. I have always had a hard time knowing he has been with other woman. What they talked about it, what they did the bedroom. It eats me alive till this day. The worst part is, I found one of the girls on FB and now I watch her everyday. I’ve talked with her many times through FB. I know that Im torturing myself and I don’t know how to stop. I don’t want to wake up one day 25 years from now and realize I’ve wasted my life worrying about my husbands ex girlfriend of how many years ago…

  33. I appreciate what you have written but the thing I find difficult is this: my husband (who had several prior partners and was involved with pornography early in our marriage) insists on certain sex acts, positions etc. or “instructs” me in bed…I feel like I am being asked to live up to these previous other experiences….this makes me resentful….I do not know how to respond. Any suggestions?

    • That is a tough one, and it likely is because he doesn’t associate sex with intimacy as much as he does sex with specific acts. If you work through the 31 Days to Great Sex with him I do talk about how to get over some of this in that book, and how to start the conversation. I also have some info in this post about marriage recovery after a porn addiction. The main talk you need to have with him, though, is that sex should be something highly intimate, not just something orgasmic (and indeed heightened intimacy makes the physical more intense anyway). It’s like you’re searching after something but you’re going at it the wrong way. I hope that helps!

  34. Thank you for this article, this really spoke to me. I hope and pray I will find relief from this jealousy soon. My husband was my first everything, my first kiss, first boyfriend, he was even the first man I went on more than one date with. I was 19 when I met him. My husband had dated, kissed, and been sexually intimate with other women. I also found out he had a porn addiction,. It just breaks my heart. I thought I would be over it by now, but it keeps me up late at night still. He has lived in this town his whole life and his partners still live around here. We run into them sometimes and its too much for me to handle. I desperately want to move away. I.am trying to forget about them but when you’re running into them it makes it difficult. I beg my husband to try to find. A job elsewhere so we can move. He doesn’t understand how painful this is for me. I just don’t know if I can ever get over this, but I have to try. :(

    • How old are you now? (How long have you been with your husband is what I’m really trying to get at). I’ve been staying awake at night (off and on) for many years now, trying to think/reason my way through my wife’s fornication (which occurred about 1 year before we met, but several years before we started dating). She knew it was seriously wrong, but decided to be a rebel and do it anyway. She mustered the willpower to decide to leave that life behind and follow Christ while away from her boyfriend during a 6-week summer camp. She weaned herself of the relationship after getting back, but not right away (it took awhile – maybe a few months). She definitely gave up that lifestyle (not dating for several years until starting to date me) before me, but in some ways hasn’t completely opened up to me about it. She’s told me things, sometimes easily, sometimes with difficulty – but I’ve never really ‘felt’ her being vulnerable about it (that’s not completely true, the night she first told me I could tell she was nervous and probably wondering if I’d just break up with her there about it). I felt privileged that she opened up to me, and also understood that there was no obligation to tell me more, so long as I wasn’t her husband. In fact, I felt like she thought the same thing – on the day before our wedding, we had a quiet moment where she gave me 1 rose and apologized for not waiting for me. I’d struggled a lot between when she first told me and then, because I knew that 3 other guys had been physically intimate with her (only 1 had sex with her), and that in a sense, I was ‘on the outside’. I felt like this was a sign (from God?) that I was on the right track and that we’d be able to completely open up about it after getting married, and probably a good cry together or something like that. I waited for 15 years like that, stewing inside, waiting for her to initiate a conversation. It never happened until I started taking the initiative – I started by keeping a journal of what I was feeling. It helped to get it out on paper, and start thinking about it more rationally. My rational side hasn’t really ever had any trouble believing in who she now is – it’s always been my emotional side that gets stuck. I thought for a long time that we’d never feel close. The conversations have been difficult, and she usually doesn’t want to have them – but it’s helped me, and also us I think, to have them nonetheless (not all the time, but from time to time). To be honest, it would help a lot if she took more initiative and showed a strong desire to put this in the past by confronting it directly with me. If I could just decide to leave it in the past, I believe I would have done so during those 15 years. It seems obvious to me that it needs to be confronted directly. She’s acted defensively in the past (both pre and post-marriage), and this tells me that she hasn’t fully addressed all the issues that stem from it. Having said this, it is much better in many ways – she better understands me and what’s going on inside me; we communicate much better, and not just about the past; I have more hope that we’ll work things out, even though I can’t quite see the way forward much of the time.

      I feel like there is a big disconnect between holding virginity as a high standard, and recognizing God’s mercy and forgiveness. It does feel like many want to emphasize mercy and forgiveness so much that the very real hurt and distrust that has entered many marriages is downplayed and the virgin spouse is made to feel like it’s because of him/her that there are problems in the marriage. I agree that mercy and forgiveness are an instrumental part of Christ’s message, but I don’t feel like we can get to that part without first recognizing the depth of injustice that has been put on the virgin spouse’s shoulders. Not that we are without sin – far from it. But sin that unites our spouse to another person, even completely outside marriage (ie, fornication instead of adultery), uniquely attacks the marriage bond. I hope that I don’t want to hold this over her head to punish her – I have many motives inside and I don’t pretend to fully understand any of them. I do believe that (one of) my most important motives is for us to genuinely live in full communion – I feel like it won’t happen until/unless we can face these difficulties fully together.

      The last 2-3 years have brought a lot of growth in our marriage. I/We intend to keep working at it.

      Although painful, I’d like to offer a suggestion to you that perhaps living where you are right now can help you to face the hurt directly. If you were to leave just to get away from them all it might feel like you were beaten by sin. I’m not suggesting that moving away would be a bad thing, just to try to do it with peace of mind.

      • I have to say this, and this is in part because of something I read somewhere else: Why hold on to something your wife chose not to have anything to do with- even before you met her? Wanting to talk about it- that is really wrong. Are you God that you choose to remind her and keep something in her mind that she doesn’t want there? God promised to forget our sins- and even though you are a virgin- I’m sure you’ve sinned in other areas- and I bet she doesn’t want to throw it in your face or make you feel uncomfortable. A woman who has stood by you for 15 years does not deserve to be put through a Perry Mason grilling. Please, let love light your way! And yes, I am a woman who had done far worse than your wife. I hate what I did! My husband also had partners beforehand as well. And even with all that, yes it is hard to think about- which is why we must choose not to. As the author said, we are now a new creation together.

  35. Thank you for the post. They are all very useful- I only wish I had read this when I first started dating my boyfriend (now husband). Before I fell in love with my husband, the first few months of dating, it didnt bother me that much that he had sex with his highschool girlfriend, we agreed to never have sex and I was just so content that I found someone who had the same values now as I did. As soon as I fell in love with him though it hit me like a brick, jealousy set in, and I did exactly what you advised not too– I asked him everything imaginable, under the sun. I did exactly what God did not want me to do, and made him feel awful about it. About a year and a half later I finally forgave him, with God’s help and we moved past it. Unfortunatley, those images still haunt me, and I wonder now even that were married, if they will ever go away. I pray about it but often I feel so weak and I wish that I had not asked him all those things. Sometimes, I reflect back on what he has told me and I am atleast happy that he was not happy and that his past relationship was hardly a relationship. However, it still seems to upset me. Thank you for the post, I will most definitley reflect on #2, and dismiss it if it does not line up with what God says.

  36. I stumbled upon this through another post of yours that I found on Pinterest! This has been something I have been struggling with for quite some time now and I thank God that I found something for me to read and re-read. I was separated from my ex-husband when I met my now husband. Before my first husband and even for a short time before my second husband, I was sleeping around. I was looking all the wrong things and was in no way romantically connected with any of these men. When I met my now husband, he was pretty much doing the same exact thing but for some reason, we were completely different with each other than we were with anyone else. No we weren’t pure until we got married, but we both actually went cherishing our relationship. While dating, I found files on his computer with pictures of previous flings…naked pictures included…and it tore me apart. I confronted him and he said he completely forgot that they were there, apologized and deleted everything but the damage had already been done. I compared myself in every way to these multiple women and these images haunted me over and over again. I learned that he had told several women he loved them when he didn’t mean it. I learned that he was more of a playboy than I ever imagined. I prayed about it over and over again and I knew it wasn’t fair to be angry towards him when my past was jaded as well. I prayed for forgiveness for myself and prayed for my relationship with my now husband. Things got better and I was able to move on and we got engaged and married. My husband treats me like his queen and always has. He’s told me how he’s ashamed of how he treated women before me and hates that I know what I do know because he doesn’t want me to think poorly of him. He has done everything he can to prove to me that he loves me more than anything in the world and I thank God daily for a wonderful and loving husband who shows me more than once a day how lucky he considers himself. Even now however, I have thoughts that creep into my mind and sometimes it’s difficult for me to rebuke them. Since reading this post, it has helped me immensely and I can’t thank you and God enough for this.

  37. Letter to my Husband’s Ex girlfiend

    Firstly let me say, I am sorry for what you went through. I am sorry that you gave something so precious and the most intimate part of yourself to the man who is now my husband. I am sorry that your heart was broken. I’m sorry that your commitment to God to stay pure before him until marriage was broken. I’m sorry that you have had years of anguish and heartache, trying hard to reckon with what happened in the relationship you had with the man who is now my husband. I’m sorry you feel he failed you.

    The man who hurt you, was a broken man. A man far from Christ. Who did not know himself or love himself, and had no ability in himself to give of himself the way you gave yourself to him. He was young, and seeking in the world, what only Christ could fill in his heart. In his seeking, he found you, and continued in his brokenness together with you. You partook in his brokenness and led him on a path further away from his purpose and his calling. What you perceived to be the “love” you were giving him, was in reality a ball and chain that sunk both of you into a pit of heartbreak and despair. You chose to give a part of yourself you had no business giving to anyone. You deceived yourself into believing he was “the one” when all the signs were there that he was not– he was only broken and seeking in world what could only be filled by Christ in his life.

    He has walked along journey since then. One that took him to the heights of the Maine mountaintops, to the depths of the heart of Jesus. He is a new man. Before God and before men. He is restored. He has found in Christ love and completeness, he never knew before. He is whole, he is healed and he is forgiven.

    On our wedding night, he experienced something he never had before. He was completely united with another being, in heart, body and soul. He became one with me, in all ways. What he has with me is far more richer than what he ever had with anyone before, including you.

    I have a beautiful life with him. He is a good husband and a great father. His greatest desire is to love me the best way he knows how and to share with me the depths of his heart. It is with me he has lives in the freedom Christ gave him and freely gives of himself to me and loves me completely. I have come to know and understand that he loves ME, he chose ME and he married ME. Anything in his past pails to the truth of the fact that after all was said and done, he chose me.

    I’m sorry you yearned for that from him, but never found it. It was not in him that you would ever find completeness, but in Christ alone, and I hope you have found that. I hope your life has led you on the path to healing and you have come to know that only the fullness of Christ can fill your hearts brokenness.
    I forgive you for steering him further into brokenness in those days.
    I forgive you for feeling entitled to a part of him you had no right laying claim to.
    I forgive you for being deceived about the source of your love and fullness and for directing affections to him that should have been reserved for Christ.
    I forgive you for compromising his purity and compromising him.

  38. Hi Sheila,

    I am a man, and I have a sexual past outside of marriage, although it isn’t as extensive, perhaps, as that of other guys. I have had one partner. I thought I was going to marry her, and it has been was very difficult to let her go. Regrettably, I was sexually active with her a number of times, and I am finding this very difficult to accept now. It was a lot easier, perhaps, because she is not a Christian. She has a rather unrestricted view of human sexuality.

    The possibility of marrying this girl is all but non-existent. However, I do not think I am able to marry someone else. I know how much pain can be experienced over the sinful past of a spouse, especially for certain types of personalities and for Christians in particular. I don’t want to put such a soul through that pain. Ever.

    For this reason, I am very afraid of opening myself up to anyone else to form a relationship that might lead to marriage. I feel that trying to overcome this fear would be callous and inconsiderate. I feel I should never allow any woman to fall in love with me, and I should kill any relationship that might be going in that direction.

    At the same time, though, I am not sure this is correct. Non-Christians are far more forgiving and understanding in this regard in my experience. Thus, I am, at least in this way, less afraid of non-Christian women than I am of good, sincere Christian women. The latter could be more easily hurt by getting close to me because of my past (which I cannot imagine ever trying to conceal!).

    This is horribly painful for me. I don’t know what to do about it. I don’t want to intentionally block women who have never sinned in this way from getting to know me more deeply. But I fear they would be the most hurt by me, and seeing that would rip my heart apart even more.

    • Paul,

      I’m sorry if I’m not reading what you wrote clearly enough, but I can’t tell if you’re approaching this from a Christian perspective. I assume that you are doing so. It’s also not at all clear how old you are, so I apologize if I’m not addressing you at the right level.

      I’m from the other side of things – where another man (well, teenage boy when she was also a teenager) fornicated with my wife. She was in rebellion at the time, and came out of it during a kind of conversion experience during this relationship. She eventually ended the relationship and didn’t date (for 5 years) until I came along.

      As I’ve written in here previously, I struggle with what my wife shared/gave away to high school boyfriends (only one was intercourse, though the others were not chaste). The repercussions of those choices still haunt (and hurt) me today. I hold here more responsible for those relationships than the guys, primarily because I know she was raised better than that, whereas from what she’s told me, they had very poor role modelling/parenting. Nevertheless, she successfully changed her life, clearly giving up those sins/sinful relationships. If we had attempted dating sooner after her conversions, I would have more reason to question her convictions, but as it is, I don’t think I can really do that. I won’t pretend that there couldn’t have been someone else out there for me, but on the whole, her presence in my life has made my life richer, even apart from the wonderful children we share. I see myself as focussing more on God’s justice when I approach this situation – even though I know/recognize that somewhere His mercy has to take over.

      I’d like to encourage you to walk the immediate road you must, which should include becoming the man who won’t take advantage of any woman, Christian or not. It seems like you’re well on the way to this, but some of it will only be proven over time (both to yourself and to others, including a potential future spouse). You don’t need to come up with an immediate answer as to your eventual vocation right away, although you do need to understand your immediate vocation and to live that faithfully. God wants a full life for each of His children, including you – but you will probably find you have to walk a narrow path to live it. That may yet include a wife who will understand and love you – probably most successfully as a humble sinner. Be patient with yourself, but impatient with any sin that creeps in (in particular sins against chastity – particularly pornography).

      My wife and I dated for about a year (knew each other as acquaintances for several years) before she told me of her past. To be honest, I already knew that I loved her by that time and that it would be a failure if I rejected her because of her past. It still hurt and intruded on the intimacy we were trying to develop. I consider it partially my own failure to know how to love and accept her fully – we’re still working through it. I do think that we should have talked more directly about what it meant before we got engaged – for both of us to have a deeper peace of mind. That’s not where we are now, so anytime we do talk about it, it feels like we’re renegotiating our relationship (which I’m sure we are to an extent). We have many good and rich aspects to our relationship – but I desperately want to get to a place where I/we can fully let this go and only move forward. I feel certain effects of her past relationships (which may or may not be real), and want to address them to embrace her fully. She feels hurt and threatened (I think) when I tell her some of the struggles that I have (in truth, I feel we both are having them, but she’s repressing them – I think she’s more or less admitted this, but she sees the ‘solution’ as both of us repressing any/all thoughts of the past). I’ve heard spiritual advice, including in here, that would more or less agree with her, but I still feel the need to address the past directly. In past ages, I think I would have challenged the guy to a duel (or somesuch) and some measure of honour would have been restored. As a Christian today, I don’t know exactly what we’re called to do. I do know that our secular culture protects sins such as these and makes people like me who feel wronged feel like we’re the ones with the problem. To an extent, modern Christianity, in practice, is indistinguishable from this – telling the wronged spouse to let it go because Christ has forgiven it. I don’t really know the right way to work through it, but am learning to pray about it better than I used to – which is giving me hope.

      Sorry for the ramble – I wish you well and expect I’ll remember to offer some prayers for you.

  39. Samantha says:

    I know this is old, but I am seeking some advice.

    I am 22 and my current boyfriend is 24. We have only been dating for a few months now, but we both take our relationship very seriously. We are both Christians who have our sexual histories…
    Mine: I am not a virgin. I slept with my first boyfriend after a few months of dating. I thought he was going to be the one. Unfortunately, it ended. However before him, I had messed around with another guy. I also, before and after my first boyfriend, engaged in cyber sex (pictures, sexting, phone sex.) I believed that even though it was wrong, it was not as bad as actually having sex with other guys. My current boyfriend and I have also engaged in sex a few times, but we have decided to try and stop all sexual activity because we want to do our relationship differently and actually walk through Christ…
    My boyfriend: I find it funny when people comment that there spouse or boyfriend has had like three partners before them… I would do anything to have that situation. My boyfriend has dated a lot of women. He has been in 13 relationships and has been sexual with all thirteen of them… I am now the 14… I think it is important to know sexual histories… but maybe not as important as we make them seem to be. I wish I didn’t know how many women he has been with… ONLY Because I am so hung up on the number 13… We are both trying to work on ourselves and us as we try and walk our relationship through Christ.
    I often feel hurt or cheated because he has been with so many women and I have not been with many guys. Sometimes I feel like there is not much left that we can experience together that would be new for the both of us.
    He tells me it was kind of rough growing up. His mom wasn’t really around and his father was emotionally and physically abusive… He didn’t have much direction. One of his relationships ended up with her being pregnant and him paying for the abortion because his mother had that much influence to make him pay for it. He still is unsure if it was even his.
    However, he tells me that he is sorry… he says it wrecks his heart knowing that it kills me inside. He thinks it is horrible that I think of myself as just another number instead of his girlfriend who he deeply cares about. He said he was an old school romantic. He was trying to find his true love and these girls didn’t have it. These girls didn’t show him the compassion, support, deep emotional connection like he has with me. He says his actions had consequences and he has had to deal with them and learn from them.

    I love everything about this guy but his sexual past is what I am really struggling with. I am not struggling with the fact that he has had prior sexual relationships before me… I am struggling with the fact that he has had so many (13) before me…

    I don’t want to feel alone in this. I feel like everytime I read the comments it reassures me until I see “Has had a few sexual partners before me.” Is it wrong for me to be with someone who has had such an extensive sexual history? Are there people, christian couples who are happily married to someone in this postion I am in?

    I want this to work out. I don’t want to end things because I can’t change his past that he has no control over. Especially since it was before he met me… I know he would give anything to have met me before he met any of these girls.

    Help!

    • Samantha,
      I do know how you are feeling. My husbands past is definitely more than 13, although I do not know the exact number. I can’t be too angry, however, because my past is jaded as well. For me, it’s not really the high number, it’s the fact that he told many of his flings that he loved them when he didn’t really mean it. One day he was saying “I love you” and not two weeks later he was done with her and on to the next. An old friend of his once told me that he wanted to write a book … Confessions of a womanizer or something along the lines. I was already head over heels in love and engaged when I learned this! He doesn’t even know I know this. I’ve learned to deal with it through prayer…that is the ONLY way I make it through. I get angry because words that I’ve only said to two men in my entire life, he spouted off to dozens of women. I’ve told him that I feel like him saying those words to me is almost a slap in the face because he obviously doesn’t hold those words high like I do. I pray everyday for God to help me get through my issues and to help me forgive him. I was no saint either so I remind myself that I am no one to judge because my husband doesn’t judge me for my past.

  40. Thank you for this post. I thought I was struggling this all alone.
    I’ve been married for 2 years now and I still struggle with this issue, not only because I know my husband had a past but I know the faces and names of the 3 women he had sex with. 1 of the women he had sex with, he is still friends with her (guess they were good friends for a long time and were friends with benefits in college… he said he had sex with her twice and it meant nothing and that this was 10 years ago). They are still friends (and friends on fb). They don’t hang out or talk to each other but I do have the agony of seeing her once a year when we go out to his hometown every summer to visit his parents/friends/family. I told her to defriend her and that I never want to see her again but she is close friends with all of his close friends and it is impossible to un-friend her or exclude her from parties when he goes home once a year. My dilemma is…would it be fair for me to still demand that he unfriend her and not invite her to parties or just let go and toughen it out once a year? I just think it’s unfair for me that I have to go through the agony.. but I also understand where my husband is coming from.
    Also, I rage at him every time this issue comes out..Hate is a strong word but I really hate my husband when I feel this way and this is a terrible thing to say but I wished I was promiscuous before marriage so I don’t have to deal with this issue.

  41. This is a great post, my issue is a little different though. My husband and I were both previously married. We were both cheated on. He has a daughter with his ex. So I see see her 3-4 times a week. Sometimes more. I have come to terms with him having sex with her. It was a real relationship like mine, it just didn’t work. I seldom think of his past relationships other than that one. When I do I feel sick just like most other girls do. But like I said my issue is a little different. My husband is not very religious. He grew up the complete opposite of me. (His mom worked in a bar and he would always hang out there after school etc) I have always had a problem with nudity. I don’t believe that my significant other should see other women naked. However, since my divorce I have gotten so insecure that I don’t even want him to see girls in bras or swimsuits. Then there is the biggest problem of all. Before my husband and I met he had gone to strip clubs. When I asked how many he said he wasn’t sure, quite a few times. He said he only went when his friends invited him. Then this morning I was organizing books and the back page of his yearbook fell off. One of the girls that signed it caught my eye b/c it was a lot a writing. She said she hoped he enjoyed throwing things down her shirt and he should calm down on the sexual comments. Now I’m aware this was 15 years ago, but in my mind it makes me feel like he is like every other guy. A disgusting perv (that’s what I keep saying in my head) I feel like between the strip clubs and the sexual comments that he doesn’t have respect for women. However, anybody that know my husband would never say that. He is so loving, caring, helpful, thoughtful, funny… everything I could ever wish for. So one end of the spectrum is everything I want and the other is everything I don’t want… I don’t know what to do anymore except cry. It’s gotten to the point where he can’t handle it anymore. :( Please help!

    • Oh my friend I know how you feel. My husband was in few words, a “womanizer.” It started in high school for him and went all the way to pretty much me. Sure he had a couple serious girlfriends, but as soon as they were over, he was hopping from woman to woman just trying to rack up his number. He won’t tell me much, I just know after piecing things together from him, his parent, his sisters and friends. The ONLY way I get through is prayer. When I start to think of who he was before me or anything that would make me angry at him, I pray. It gets easier every time. It might take some time, but God can help you through it. My husband is so loving and passionate with me and I have a sense of pride knowing that I was different, something special that he obviously couldn’t find with anyone else. Don’t let something evil take away some of your happiness.

  42. Thank you Tami! I have been praying a lot. I have even been to counseling. I just feel… lost and scared. All I hear from his friends and family are great things. How anyone would be lucky to be married to him and I’m one lucky girl. I so believe that, which is why I want to be able to let this go. I’ve been struggling for years now and nothings helped. So I just can’t help but feel disconnected and alone. It’s to the point where I lie in bed at night for hours. B/c when I try to sleep my mind wonders to negative thoughts.

  43. anonymous says:

    I have an issue as well- that I am felt to made to feel so wrong about.
    I am engaged to a man and we have two children together. I cannot seem to let go of the fact that he had/has a best friend who is female. they were sexual and intimate before but they stopped it and decided to just be friends so as to not ruin their friendship. she knows a lot about him and his past. I am not comfortable with this, j have asked him to cease contact with her out of respect for our relationship and what I feel is the sanctity of what is our relationship and eventually to be our marriage.
    he tells me, ‘I don’t think you’d like it very much if I told you who you can be friends with and who you can’t, especially when those individuals have held a place of importance in ones life many times longer than their partner has even been known to them. ‘
    that to me is really bothering me. I so not think she should hold such a place in his life currently or in our future because I feel that her place will compromise mine. I am not ok with another woman being the person he thinks of so highly in that sense because I feel that intimacy is for him and I alone.
    he tells me that she will forever be his friend.
    am i alone in feeling that it isn’t appropriate? I feel I have a right to be uncomfortable knowing their history. he claims it was innocent and that their relationship is completely platonic. I feel that the sexual stuff they shared (come on, they touched each other’s genitals and were intimate together!) completely cancels out that sense of being platonic.
    please advise, it makes me feel absolutely uncomfortable and insecure. he tells me I’m incapable of trust because of that but to me it isn’t that- it is it all as a whole.
    for what it’s worth, he has stopped telling her everything because I felt so strongly about it but it is ‘an argument’ because he just doesn’t agree with me in regards to her significance being more for the past and those times during their lives. I feel like that is fine to respect that they had it but it needs to remain in the past. I cannot help but not like feeling she still means THAT much to him. it really bothers me. please help.

    thank you

    • Yes, I agree with you. I think that because it has crossed the line, it can never be a pure friendship. Also, since he was so close with her, even if they hadn’t had sex, it might be of a concern. You should marry your best friend- which is why I don’t like that movie (but I digress). My husband and I both had a sordid past. I had relationships because I was so desperate to get married and not feel lonely that I jumped into a lot of stupid mistakes, and I have been married before my husband. So, when we started dating we deleted all our contacts eventually that had anything to do with sex or prospective members of the opposite sex, even if they were just friends- but had been more or were when we were looking for just someone to talk to. So, while we couldn’t undo anything in our past, we can keep it in the past, and the more you keep it there and let it go, the less you think about it. Like, when I would think about his times at a strip club and lap dances, I would get so angry, but he forgave me of things so that helps. Plus I know that sin may be fun for a season the emptiness and guilt that goes along with it are not. Try to express this to him at a good time your thoughts. Maybe a pastor or counselor could offer premarital advice. Our pastor does not see women alone. He does that to keep himself for his wife alone and avoid all temptation.

  44. Wow the comments on this post are still going strong! There’s a lot of despair out there about this! Shane it sounds like you are especially in despair about this since it still has you up at night after 19 years. It is possible that you are experiencing depression that stems from this and I have been there! You have to address that and heal it or you are really in danger. God loves you and your wife so much! Our story is a very long one that could probably help and offer hope and encouragement to many people that have commented here. Our story is one of past sexual sin, the baggage and pain it brought to the marriage, the obsession with it, and how we healed beyond our wildest dreams. The details are long and I could honestly write a book about our journey and have actually thought about it. What I will say here is that my husband and I did something that others may consider quite odd. Especially considering that we had been married about 19 years at that point. We had 4 children as well. But we continued to struggle with pain about each of us being with others 25 years prior. At about year 18, our sexual relationship became very intense and we connected on a level that we had never before experienced in the nearly 20 year marriage. Although we were Christians all our lives and had been involved in many aspects of our church, what was changing our relationship was a new connection to Christ. We were able to have extremely open discussions about sexual desires, our souls, fears, hopes, dreams, and God. When we were together physically we put in worship songs and it became our go-to music for sex. Due to our newfound love for each other, my husband began to grieve DEEPLY with the fact that we had both been with others. There was anger not only that I had given the gift to another, but even more so about his own sexual past. He was really angry with himself, his parents (for not talking to him about purity) and at our culture. He, along with our spiritual counsel, came up with a plan for healing. We agreed to go back to courting. I was not at all happy about this at first since we had just began this intense relationship. This was kind of like Love Dare from the movie Fireproof. Here’s the VERY odd part— during this time we prayed for spiritual restoration of our virginity. During this time we abstained from sex for almost a year. I don’t even think we saw each other naked. We prayed for each other and we prayed that God could do the impossible and somehow restore our minds, spirits, and souls to virginity. We slept in the same bed and sometimes we kissed and caressed each other but we never took it further. As soon as we felt things starting to get too intense, we pulled back and just held each other. It was an amazing experience. It brought us so close during that time. I remember a particular night that we lay across from each other with about a foot between us with the lights on and our toddler between us and we had just listened to “More Precious Than Silver” and then came on the song “Open Our Eyes” by Teri DeSario. We had a deeply spiritual experience. I can only speak for myself on what happened, but it felt like I was looking at God’s Adam and I felt like my soul was suspended slightly above my body like resting on a floating feather on a quiet stream. Jesus was right there 100% almost like Jesus was covering our bodies in a blanket of His love. I started to cry out of joy and without my telling him what I was experiencing or asking him what he felt, my husband said he felt something happening. Our toddler was asleep between us the whole time. This happened at the end of that year of courting, about 3 days before we were set to renew our vows in church. We had been planning the renewal for the end of our year of abstinence, courting, and seeking God. We had a new unity candle custom made with our vows on it and our names a the “new” date. When I walked down the aisle in my dress, the way my husband looked at me, I knew that God had done the impossible. I knew that it was as if we had never even dated or kissed another. It was unbelievable. My husband had so much joy and emotion during this ceremony. We had both prepared for that “wedding night” by reading literature about sex as God meant it to be. There are many great books out there. We especially like Heaven’s Song by Christopher West and Sheet Music. We completely redecorated our bedroom including new furniture and I prepared by picking out the right things to wear for later that night. When we came home to our new bridal suite that night, I can honestly say that our souls had been returned to purity and virginity. My husband had been with 5-6 people in the years before meeting me, and I had been with 1 other, and previously my husband and I had not abstained from premarital sex with each other. But the night of our renewal, we can honestly say it was the first time for both of us. The first time we ever experienced sex as God really intended it. It was deeply spiritual and nothing or no one mattered that night or ever again. We first danced to the song “I could sing of your love forever” about 5 times. We both had a brand new experience that we felt was a gift straight from God. There were tears of joy too. After 20 years of marriage and 4 kids, it was the BEGINNING of our marital covenant. We do somewhat grieve over the lost years in our marriage, but when I think of my wedding night, it is that night I think of and the joy. There is no more pain or even thoughts of past sexual sins with other people or even with each other. We were completely healed. In fact, I’m not even sure how I stumbled upon this post. We have now been married 23 years and have since had a 5th baby. Sorry this was long, but I want to encourage those suffering that there is hope in your future. I can say I didn’t even know what marital love was until year 20! Hang in there! If you are already in a covenant marriage, it belongs to God and I promise you that with all his power He will heal it! But you have to stop obsessing and asking questions about the past and just start LOVING! When you start loving like that, your marriage will explode. I do want to be sure to mention that if anyone were to do what we did, I think a whole year might not be necessary and that you both have to be 100% in because we are not to withhold sex from our spouse who desires it. And for those dating or engaged, WAIT! Even if you’ve had a past sexual partner, keep sex with your spouse until after the wedding night. Don’t rob yourself of the joy of your wedding night and honeymoon because it will be very difficult to get that back if ever. When you wait, there will be joy instead of a feeling of what could have been, which is what I felt on my first wedding night 23 years ago. God bless you and your marriage!

  45. I can’t believe I’m going to leave another long comment after I just did, but I’m stuck today and can’t get a thing done because Shane’s situation is weighing so heavily on my heart and I can see that by the dates of his post that he still reads here on occasion. So I apologize to all and to the moderator if another long post is totally inappropriate. Shane — I went back and very carefully read your posts. I see myself in your wife. I didn’t want to talk to my husband about my past because I was so very desperate for him to see me as a sweet, innocent girl. Although his sexual past was painful for me, I was more obsessed that I wasn’t a virgin for him, especially since he had the experience of deflowering an ex-girlfriend. I felt like he experienced that with her and couldn’t with me. I wasted my virginity on a loser and the fact that I couldn’t give that gift to my husband but his ex did made me rage with jealousy. It was so bad– I was so obsessed about her that I kind of became anorexic early in our marriage. I felt like she was the innocent virgin and I was a slut. It affected the kind of sex my husband and I had for DECADES. I was (or ACTED) very passive and sweet (maybe what you called “cautious”). Passion in me was there but I had it bolted down so tightly. I don’t know why or how but one day after 18 years, I texted my husband and asked him a very bold question completely out of my nature and his answer absolutely floored me. And the floodgates opened. He literally left his office, drove straight home where I met him at the door and we just threw our arms around each other. He poured his heart out and so did I. For 18 years we had both been suppressing it all. For a year after that we had an intense emotional and sexual relationship that went on for over a year before we began the year of abstinence. We were able to talk through everything and that’s when we discovered how much pain there really was there and how much healing needed to be done. It wasn’t just past sexual sins, it was also that I learned about how babies are made by accidentally stumbling onto some porn in a bathroom where I was babysitting. It was also horrible comments my dad made about me when he found out I had been physical with my high school boyfriend. The first and really only man to call me a slut was my own father. My husband has very negative feelings towards my father over that because it affected life in the marital bed. My husband turned it all around. The year of abstinence helped me to feel innocent again and without too much detail, the night of our renewal he treated me like no man had ever touched me before. I am now free with him, not cautious and I trust him enough to know that no matter what I say or do in the bedroom, he is never going to think badly because I am HIS girl. I think your wife may be suffering more than you realize and not wanting to talk is…… how can I say this….. for 18 years of our marriage, I lived with a negative self-image of maybe my husband thinks I’m a slut, so I was closed off big time. I was the sweetest girl in bed there ever was and never did or said any of the things I wanted to. We lived like that for 18 years. I thought that’s what he wanted. I was SO wrong. He wanted the passion and the full communion. He wanted me to say everything that came into my head and he sure had a lot to say too! For the first time we were doing something that had never happened in 18 years— looking at each other and smiling at each other during sex. 18 years of NO trust and then one day God just rained down on us! There’s hope for you my friend. I can almost guarantee your wife has those feelings, especially since you remain so upset over it. She’s broken and you can definitely fix it. You’re going to have to re-court without asking about her sexual past. I hear your desire to know everything and that you think it will help you heal. That is a feeling, and sometimes feelings lie. Too much information will kill you. I had way too much info. about my husbands past. Images that stayed with me, even long after he couldn’t even remember what his ex looked like anymore much less what happened, how it happened, etc. Let your wife know that you find her sweet, beautiful, lovely and that you are intrigued by her innocence and it is very likely that passion may erupt. That’s what my husband did.

  46. Kam,

    Thank you for your thoughtful words – it does mean a lot to me that you took the time to relate your experiences in here. Some parts of what you write definitely seem relevant and I’ll give them more thought and prayer. There is definitely a kind of battle going on inside of me – I wish I could say that the end was in sight, but I don’t see a lot of change in my thought patterns from over the past 19 years. A part of me thinks that if I can’t get it together and fully accept and forgive my wife as she is, then what else could she tell me that would change this? The other part thinks that complete openness is the way to go, even beyond the many things that she’s already told me – there’s another web-site that had some advice that struck me – it talked about how, generally speaking, the ‘spouse with a past’ probably wouldn’t have to go into lots of detail, but that s/he should be prepared to go as far as the other spouse wants, just to make sure that both are aware that there aren’t any secrets. Like I say, I don’t see a quick resolution, but will keep hoping and praying for one – and would appreciate your prayers as well – it’s very difficult for my wife and I not to see eye to eye about this. I’ll have to seriously look at how you and your husband worked through things.

  47. I didn’t know so many people felt like this. I thought I was crazy . I think about my husbands past all the time and I don’t know why because I had sex with one person before I met my husband . Maybe it is because he lied about the number of sex partners or who they were. I probably shouldn’t have asked. Isometimes I wonder if this is Gods punishment for me because I did not wait until I was married and I promised him I would. I have been to the point of wanting my life to end because I don’t feel like we share anything special with each other because we both gave all of ourselves to others before.

    • I definitely know the feeling of crazy. My wife and I have had a lot of ups and downs about this – I find it very difficult to predict when either will come, because they both seem to start with me initiating conversations about it. Sometimes she reacts negatively – it’s especially difficult because sometimes I feel like I’ve got a breakthrough for us, but it hasn’t really come yet. A couple weeks ago (after my last post), I felt at peace – it lasted for a little less than a week. She told me a couple new things about her past, and they both took a hit out of me (I can’t really fault her for talking, I’ve told her that I want her to talk and that I’m open to it) – the difficulty is that they’re new and unexpected. For example, after she had her conversion (to Jesus and to chastity) following her last boyfriend, she told me that she’d been very chaste for 5 years (ie, before we started dating). She was trying to tell me about a time after this that she’d said ‘no’ to a guy, and her example was of a guy a year after her last boyfriend who she didn’t have sex with – the problem is what she did do – she met him through friends one night (they were trying to hook her up to fit in better with what they were doing)(also, he was a pastor’s son) – she was working away from home that summer and she let him come in her room later that same evening, with no one else there, and they made out, including letting him feel her breasts (she tells me nothing below the waist, but I have trouble believing her now). She says she slept on the top bunk, but let him sleep on the bottom one (and that nothing further happened with him). She meant it as an example of being chaste, but it showed profoundly-bad judgement, in my opinion, and I just don’t know now who else may pop up from her past – she admitted that she went to confession after that episode (we’re Catholic), so she must have known it was wrong, even at the time.

      • I can only say from experience to let the past STAY in the past. I understand your want to know, trust me, but all you’re going to get is heartache. I don’t have much room to be upset with my husband as I was pretty much in the same boat as he was in, I just never said things that I didn’t mean. I jumped around from guy to guy because I just didn’t want to be alone and when I met my husband, I was thinking that he’d only be around for a short while. I never even expected to find the love of my life, and neither did my husband! He has no desire to know anything about my past relationships and I wish I had the same mind as he does. He knows about the important ones in my life, but there’s not many. He did tell me about the “important” ones but I learned from friends and family about others and then I stumbled upon things I wish that I hadn’t. I understand the hurt that comes because I hate myself for the things I did with other guys and wish that I could have saved all of those experiences for my husband. I hate that he too shared sexual intimacies with many women as well as tell women he loved them when he knows he didn’t mean it. You have to remember that your spouse is not that person anymore. I tell myself that all the time. I also saw a little quote that helped me even more…basically it said how can you expect someone who’s trying to be a better person to want to continue when you remind them of the person they used to be. Why keep having your wife re-live those moments in her life when she should be forgetting them. You probably remember things about her past clearer than she does. The best thing is to leave it be. Your wife chose you, you were her choice over anything and everyone else.

Comment Policy: Please stay positive with your comments. If your comment is rude, it gets deleted. Any comment that espouses an anti-marriage philosophy (eg. porn, adultery, abuse and the like) will be deleted. If it is critical, please make it constructive. If you are replying to another commenter, please be polite and don't assume you know everything about his or her situation. If you are constantly negative or a general troll, you will get banned. The definition of terms is left solely up to us. Sheila Wray Gregoire owns the copyright to all comments and may publish them in whatever form she sees fit. She agrees to keep any publication of comments anonymous, even if you are not anonymous on this board.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] this post and would like to see what other awesome bloggers are posting about marriage, click here to visit “Wifey Wednesdays” at To Love, Honor and Vacuum with Sheila Wray Gregoire!) [...]

  2. [...] Getting Over Your Husband’s Sexual Past – Did your husband have other sexual relationships before you were married? Did you? How you think about this can either free you or hold you back in your marriage. Rate this:Like This? Share it:MoreLike this:LikeBe the first to like this. This entry was posted in Blog Love, Christian Marriage, Growing Strong Marriages, Happy Hour and tagged Christian, God, Husband, Intimate relationship, marriage, Paul, Relationships, Wife. Bookmark the permalink. ← Worldview Makes All The Difference [...]

  3. [...] Getting over the Jealousy of Your Husband’s Sexual Past [...]

  4. […] you’re having trouble getting over your husband’s sexual past, though, this may […]

Leave a Comment

*

CommentLuv badge